Drop Phaneuf for Matheson? Keeper

[ncslammer]

I'm keeping Phaneuf around with no intention of keeping him, putting up no points but is helping with PIMS. Thinking long-term Matheson is a better option? Can only keep 3 Dmen though.

***also I have Michael Stone no longer on IR, so drop him and pick up Matheson?

[PenguinHunter]

I don't think you are going to keep either of these players over Josi, Ekblad, Vatanen and Pietreangelo.... therefore I would play the one that is going to put up most points in your league this year.

I think Matheson will get more points so as long as PIMs are not worth an absurd amount I would make this move!

[Eskimo Brother]

I don't think you are going to keep either of these players over Josi, Ekblad, Vatanen and Pietreangelo.... therefore I would play the one that is going to put up most points in your league this year.

I think Matheson will get more points so as long as PIMs are not worth an absurd amount I would make this move!

I'm with PH. Look at it as a 1 yr. The +/- is also a killer for Phaneuf, so I go Matheson too.

[lucafen4]

I'd drop Phaneuf to well, drop Phaneuf. so yes I'd also add Matheson

if it's PIM you need... is Gudas an option to add? He won't hurt your +/- as much as Phaneuf.

[ncslammer]

It's head to head so PIMs would be nice, not crucial if other categories are lacking though.

[stevegamer]

Knowing the categories would be nice, but I agree dropping Phanuef for Matheson would be good. Might be even better out there, though.

[havanablast21]

Like what I've seen of Matheson. I'd take the gamble over Phaneuf personally.