Keeper Help ~ rep

[Laendarian]

12 Team Yahoo rotisserie league, daily starts.

Stats counted are: G A +- PIM PPP SHP SOG W GAA SV SHO

Positions include: CC LL RR DDDD Util Util GG BN BN BN BN

Which 6 would you keep from the team below?


Alex Ovechkin Was - LW
Jamie Benn Dal - LW
Max Pacioretty Mon - LW
Shayne Gostisbehere Phi - D
John Klingberg Dal - D
Matt Duchene Col - C
Kevin Shattenkirk StL - D
Tomas Hertl SJ - C
Patric Hornqvist Pit - RW
Jakob Silfverberg Anh - RW
Hampus Lindholm Anh - D
Derek Stepan NYR - C
Scott Hartnell Cls - LW
Trevor Daley Pit - D
Erik Haula Min - C,LW
Braden Holtby Was - G
Devan Dubnyk Min - G
Sergei Bobrovsky Cls - G

[PenguinHunter]

Alex Ovechkin Was - LW
Jamie Benn Dal - LW
Max Pacioretty Mon - LW
Shayne Gostisbehere Phi - D
John Klingberg Dal - D
Matt Duchene Col - C
Kevin Shattenkirk StL - D
Tomas Hertl SJ - C
Patric Hornqvist Pit - RW
Jakob Silfverberg Anh - RW
Hampus Lindholm Anh - D
Derek Stepan NYR - C
Scott Hartnell Cls - LW
Trevor Daley Pit - D
Erik Haula Min - C,LW
Braden Holtby Was - G
Devan Dubnyk Min - G
Sergei Bobrovsky Cls - G

[Shota]

Ovechkin, Benn, Gostisbehere, Klingberg, Holtby, Dubnyk

[Eskimo Brother]

Ovie
Benn
Patches
Ghost
Kling
Holtby

[PenguinHunter]

Ovechkin, Benn, Gostisbehere, Klingberg, Holtby, Dubnyk

The reason that I choose Bobrovsky over Dubnyk is that Tortella will have the team playing 100% defense first and Bobrovsky was amazing at the World Cup.

Minnesota has a new coach and therefore new system that Minnesota will have to learn... might result in a tough start for Dubnyk. but both are good options for your 6th keeper.

[Eskimo Brother]

The reason that I choose Bobrovsky over Dubnyk is that Tortella will have the team playing 100% defense first and Bobrovsky was amazing at the World Cup.

Minnesota has a new coach and therefore new system that Minnesota will have to learn... might result in a tough start for Dubnyk. but both are good options for your 6th keeper.

Both have question marks and are probably replaceable in the draft. I went with Patches and his high floor/high ceiling combo.

[Shota]

The reason that I choose Bobrovsky over Dubnyk is that Tortella will have the team playing 100% defense first and Bobrovsky was amazing at the World Cup.

Minnesota has a new coach and therefore new system that Minnesota will have to learn... might result in a tough start for Dubnyk. but both are good options for your 6th keeper.

Yep both are good options and I have them ranked pretty close... End of the day I went with the goalie on the better team

[Shota]

Both have question marks and are probably replaceable in the draft. I went with Patches and his high floor/high ceiling combo.

With 12 teams and category ratio at 6:4 (SHP doesn't really count) I would prefer having 2 starters going into the draft and then drafting a solid third goalie early/mid draft. I would seriously consider keeping Patches too though

[lucafen4]

12 Team Yahoo rotisserie league, daily starts.

Stats counted are: G A +- PIM PPP SHP SOG W GAA SV SHO

Positions include: CC LL RR DDDD Util Util GG BN BN BN BN

Which 6 would you keep from the team below?


Alex Ovechkin Was - LW
Jamie Benn Dal - LW
Max Pacioretty Mon - LW
Shayne Gostisbehere Phi - D
John Klingberg Dal - D
Matt Duchene Col - C
Kevin Shattenkirk StL - D
Tomas Hertl SJ - C
Patric Hornqvist Pit - RW
Jakob Silfverberg Anh - RW
Hampus Lindholm Anh - D
Derek Stepan NYR - C
Scott Hartnell Cls - LW
Trevor Daley Pit - D
Erik Haula Min - C,LW
Braden Holtby Was - G
Devan Dubnyk Min - G
Sergei Bobrovsky Cls - G

The 1st 5 were basically gimme's for me... Ghost was my last choice and I like his upside over Shattenkirk's given production. He showed at the world cup he's not a complete flash in the pan. He's got Mad skills..

It really came down to Ghost or Dubnyk for me. But Ghost just looks like last year wasn't a fluke.

[ztking]

Ovie
Benn
Kling
Ghost
Shatty
Holtby

[RizzeeDizzee]

Put me down as only Holtby for goalies, and I agree with Ovi, Benn, and Klingberg. That leaves two spots. I think you should pick guys who (a) will assuredly produce, and (b) won't be easy to redraft. Note that if you don't opt to keep them, both Shattenkirk and Hornqvist are sneaky good in this league.

[Laendarian]

Thanks for all the feedback guys. Interesting to see things a little different from everyone. I'm surprised Duchene didn't make anyone's list as I had him as an option in the 6th spot with a few of the others listed here

[Eskimo Brother]

With 12 teams and category ratio at 6:4 (SHP doesn't really count) I would prefer having 2 starters going into the draft and then drafting a solid third goalie early/mid draft. I would seriously consider keeping Patches too though

If you were going to go with 2G, then I would drop Ghost for Dubnyk. Patches is 100% on my list though.

[ztking]

If you were going to go with 2G, then I would drop Ghost for Dubnyk. Patches is 100% on my list though.

With Ovie and Benn in a start 2LW it turned me off. Love Patches, I'd trade him but I think having other talent at other positions is important too

[Eskimo Brother]

With Ovie and Benn in a start 2LW it turned me off. Love Patches, I'd trade him but I think having other talent at other positions is important too

I don't mind it considering there's 2 UTIL spots too. Otherwise I may have agreed with you.