Rank'em please...

[Potatoeman]

For the league in my signature (note : SHOG is for shootout goals, not shots on goal)

I currently have Guryanov in my farm team, but I'm wondering if I should drop him if I'm able to draft either C.White, N.Schmaltz or Z.Senyshyn (I know less people are high on him, but I sort of have this weird hunch that I should grab him while I can).

So how would you rank these 4 prospects? Wait time would only be a tie-breaker for me since I can keep players in my farm team as long as I want.

Thanks!

[Eskimo Brother]

White
Schmaltz
Guryanov
Senyshyn

Would be my ranking of the four.

[Deuces6]

Spot on EB!

[Jouko-Pouko]

White
Guryanov
Senyshyn
Schmaltz

This is how I'd rank them, so grab White if you can but otherwise keep Guryanov.

[Sulla]

I know you mention wait time as a non factor really but for me I always look at it as adding additional value - why? 1) reduced weight time and subsequently 2) a quicker return on investment. When players get close, or make the NHL, their hype train goes through the roof meaning that generally you can get a solid NHL asset(s) back of traded in this 'tinted glasses' period. Also trading a more ready prospect for one with marginal upside but further back re development or opportunity usually means you never see the rewards of it and that prospect you drafted two seasons ago doesn't actually turn into anything for 4/5/6 years plus as you keep trading him away... Anyway just my 2c

[als_revenge]

I'd go White for sure. I wouldn't go Schmaltz. The other two are really just a coin flip for me.

[Potatoeman]

Huh... I was expecting a little more Schmaltz love honestly. Before posting, I had my list pretty much as Eskimo Brother : White, Schmaltz, Guryanov, Senyshyn and was expecting to see variations on White and Schmaltz's order, but here I see that about half have Schmaltz 2nd and the other half have him last on the list.

I guess this is why these boards are so useful!

[Eskimo Brother]

Prospect rankings are always suspect and biased at best.
You're never going to find a good consensus on prospects, and if you do, they're probably wrong. It's just so tough to project that far into the future with players.

[keytolife]

White is def the best of the bunch here IMO. And i am much higher on Sensyhn as most are. I personally have him as a 2nd here.

[StuntMan12]

White
Schmaltz
Guryanov
Senyshyn

Would be my ranking of the four.

Agree with this as well.

[Axeman33]

I also prefer White from that group the most.

[Ingolo]

I like EB's list as well. White jumps out for me as the best option by a decent margin.

[jml238]

White
Schmaltz
Guryanov
Senyshyn

Would be my ranking of the four.

I second this!