Elliott vs Talbot vs Mrazek

[Leafs2010]

1 year H2H, daily starts; W, SV%, GAA, SVS. How would you rank these guys next year?

[4T2]

Elliott has the best team in front of him and should be the clear cut number 1 on Calgary, the only concern is injuries but I still take him ahead of the others. Talbot would be second for me because who knows if this is the year that the Oilers finally start winning. I wouldn't be surprised to see them make the playoffs, I also wouldn't be surprised to see them at the bottom of the league. Mrazek is probably still looking at too much of a timeshare with Howard to put him with the other two, so I have him a distant third.

[Eskimo Brother]

Agreed with 4T2's ranking:

Elliott
Talbot

Mrazek

[Axeman33]

Talbot
Elliott
Mrazek

[PenguinHunter]

Talbot and Elliot are close for me... Mrazek I just don't like Detroit enough to get you wins.

If I were you I would swing for the fence and go with Talbot... if the Oilers start winning than your are golden... if their D sucks again you get a lot of saves.

[glorybe23]

Elliott has the best D in front of him, and he's the better goaltender going into this season then the other 3. There is a chance that Talbot pulls a Martin Jones this season, but frankly the Oilers still need more help on the back end to push him ahead of Elliott in my eyes.

Besides the saves category, I think Elliott will come out on top for you in all the other goalie cats.

[franklin]

Talbot
Elliott
Mrazek

[Sam]

Mrazek is the most talented of the bunch. I always go by the theory that cream rises to the top. (eventually)

[Leafs2010]

I thought there would be more love for Mrazek. Cherrypicking here, but Mrazek's pre all-star numbers were unreal 2.03 .932.

[markpiel]

Mrazek
Talbot
Elliott

You just can't count on Elliott staying healthy and getting the starts.

Slight edge to Mrazek because the Red Wings still have the better team D but Edmonton is closing the gap.