Rate these goaltending prospects

[You Don't Know Jack]

I have the following goaltending prospects on my team. Goaltenders are valuable in the league and I'm looking or an eventual replacement for Luongo.

Which of my prospects has the best chance at a full time roster spot in the NHL?

My rank

1. Stolarz
2. Copley
3. Lindgren
4. Wilams, S
5. Skapski
6. Garteig
7. Dansk
8. Tomek

I can pick up McIntyre who is available for a simple drop of Stromwall.

Thoughts?

[Sulla]

you will be waiting a long time...

[You Don't Know Jack]

you will be waiting a long time...

Wasn't the question. I already know that.

[Sulla]

by the time they reach it though the whole outlook for each team could be completely different? I.e. Stolarz is right now the closest (TBH your list as it is is probably about right). But if they re up Mason and NEuvirth he will ride the pine, or if Lyon shows himself to be their next goalie he will ride the pine.... speculating on both an organisational depth chart three/four years down the road when these guys are probably ready will be almost impossible IMO

[stevegamer]

Stolarz is the guy with the best shot, because:

1. He is furthest along in the journey, and
2. There is nobody signed past this year in front of him, and
3. Both Mason & Neuwirth have question marks.

I think Stolarz makes the NHL to stay in 2017-18, and will be at worst the backup.

[The Black Panther]

Stolarz is the guy with the best shot, because:

1. He is furthest along in the journey, and
2. There is nobody signed past this year in front of him, and
3. Both Mason & Neuwirth have question marks.

I think Stolarz makes the NHL to stay in 2017-18, and will be at worst the backup.

For now this is probably your best answer.

[havanablast21]

You're right to place Stolarz at the top of you list.

I have little confidence the others ever make the NHL and if they do, little confidence in their fantasy value. But I can't focus that far down the line. I think we're talking 2020 and that makes my Brian hurt.

[Noddes55]

Stolarz is the only one I'd be looking at right now

[als_revenge]

I think McIntryre is better than half the G prospects on your list, so if you can sign him for squat you might as well...

Regarding your list, since everyone is so far off, it becomes the game of guessing. I'd move Tomek up on that list.