Andersen or Elliott

[LEAFS225]

Who is the better own this season?

[ericdaoust]

I'd go with Elliott without hesitation.

[Atomic Wedgy]

What are your scoring categories?

- - - Updated - - -

The first time I read Anderson not Andersen. I think Elliott will be better you tell me you have some crazy stats.

[Eskimo Brother]

Elliott for me as well.

[StuntMan12]

Elliot for me as well

[Sulla]

Elliott... The biggest criticism of him is health and Andersen has probably had a similiar amount of injuries

[2014olympicgold]

Elliott, but I’d trade him off before he gets tired. He’s never played over 55games in a year, and that was back in 2010. Andersen played 53games back in 2014-15 season, and is 4yrs younger. I think he has the ability to start more games than Elliot, but Elliott can put up better numbers just not for too long. He’s a great sell well hot I think.

[sasquatch]

Elliot this year and maybe next, Andersen after that

[The Black Panther]

Elliott but have finger on FA list for his backup.

[havanablast21]

Man... Probably Elliott, but I'm a gambler and I'd roll the dice on Andersen this year. This leaf team should be better than last years team and Reimer put up good numbers on that train wreck last year. I see Andersen as a better technical tender (Reimer just couldn't control rebounds) ... So I wouldn't be shocked to see Andersen actually post decent fantasy numbers this year.

I'd go Andersen for a boom/bust pick for this year vs Elliott. But I'm crazy! (And a looking to defend my 3rd consecutive championship)

Disclaimer, I've been rumoured to be a distant relative to Bondon when it comes to goalie luck. So beware.

[The Black Panther]

Man... Probably Elliott, but I'm a gambler and I'd roll the dice on Andersen this year. This leaf team should be better than last years team and Reimer put up good numbers on that train wreck last year. I see Andersen as a better technical tender (Reimer just couldn't control rebounds) ... So I wouldn't be shocked to see Andersen actually post decent fantasy numbers this year.

I'd go Andersen for a boom/bust pick for this year vs Elliott. But I'm crazy! (And a looking to defend my 3rd consecutive championship)

Disclaimer, I've been rumoured to be a distant relative to Bondon when it comes to goalie luck. So beware.

Definitely not crazy. U make a good point about Andersen.
Elliott has lots of ifs.
Consistancy, injuries, how many gps, does Calgary rebound???
Saying that the only cat on the surface Andersen may beat him at is SV℅.
ELLIOTT just isn't the be all end all.