Ghost for Puljarvi or Ehlers

[adamson]

I have ghost and was offered Puljarvi or Ehlers for him. I am d heavy and could use a rw. Should I do it and for whom?

[CascadeFilly]

I'm inclined to say go for it. I'd lean towards Pul, but they're both amazing players in great situations. More info about your team and league would help, but that's how I'd lean without knowing more.

[Eskimo Brother]

I'm inclined to say go for it. I'd lean towards Pul, but they're both amazing players in great situations. More info about your team and league would help, but that's how I'd lean without knowing more.

In your situation I would go for it too. Pulj is probably the right pick, but if you want help next season to go for it, Ehlers may be the better choice.

[dino200022]

I would say yes and as well lean toward Pully...he will get a long look to ride shotgun with Mcdavid

[hockeyrobot]

I'd wanna see your lineup and setup before making that kind of move. I've been fooled by Edmonton prospects before

[adamson]

I'm inclined to say go for it. I'd lean towards Pul, but they're both amazing players in great situations. More info about your team and league would help, but that's how I'd lean without knowing more.

Thanks to all of you for feedback. More info on my team below: 16 team, 50 playr roster (23 active , and 27 minor league players - categories: g, a, sog, +/-, hits, special team points, time on ice, blocked shots) oh and we use real player salaries (cap is real nhl x 20% so elc are real good)

Starting rosters are 3 C / 3 rw / 3 lw / 6 d / 1 utility / 1g

Getzlaf
Sam bennett
Brock nelson
Tyler johnson
Zetterberg
Abdelkader
Rafl
Kessel
Okposo
Pavelski
Kuhnackl
Doughty
Ghost
Brodie
Hamilton
Stralman
Daley
Boychuk
Hutton
Wisnieski
Brian elliot
Vasilevski
Chad johnson
Raanta

[HRM Fantasy Fan]

I am in a similar size league and I also own Gostisbehere and I wouldn't make that trade for either of those players. High end D is much more scarce than forwards. The jury is still out on Gostisbehere but what he did last year was special and he out produced Ehlers. I would also disagree that you are that strong at D I see doughty and Gostisbehere after that I think there is room for improvement. There are players like Ehlers and Puljarvi every year in the draft.

[Axeman33]

I'd send Gostisbehere out for either of those prospects, preferably Ehlers.

I am more confident in Ehlers being able to replicate and increase what we've seen from him over Gostisbehere.

[CascadeFilly]

Thanks to all of you for feedback. More info on my team below: 16 team, 50 playr roster (23 active , and 27 minor league players - categories: g, a, sog, +/-, hits, special team points, time on ice, blocked shots) oh and we use real player salaries (cap is real nhl x 20% so elc are real good)

Starting rosters are 3 C / 3 rw / 3 lw / 6 d / 1 utility / 1g

Getzlaf
Sam bennett
Brock nelson
Tyler johnson
Zetterberg
Abdelkader
Rafl
Kessel
Okposo
Pavelski
Kuhnackl
Doughty
Ghost
Brodie
Hamilton
Stralman
Daley
Boychuk
Hutton
Wisnieski
Brian elliot
Vasilevski
Chad johnson
Raanta

Yeah, I'd make a swap. Both Ehlers and Puljujarvi are great. Can't really go wrong.

[Sulla]

Ehlers for me.... would try and squeeze a minor piece out too though