Keeper League: F. Andersen vs Rinne

[seanavery]

Who would you rather have? Stats are GS, W, L, GA, GAA, SV%, Saves, Minutes Played

[Eazy BZ]

I'm in the same situation, I own both. The sense I get around the boards is that if you're trying to win now, 1-2 year window, go with Rinne. He's on a bonafide playoff team with excellent D. If you can wait another year or two, go with the younger Andersen.

[Kofax]

I'm in the same situation, I own both. The sense I get around the boards is that if you're trying to win now, 1-2 year window, go with Rinne. He's on a bonafide playoff team with excellent D. If you can wait another year or two, go with the younger Andersen.

Ya, this is what I was thinking. Rinne will likely provide the better stats for the next couple years, while Andersen provides better longterm value.

[havanablast21]

Andersen for me. As soon as this year potentially... but long term Keeper value... Andersen hands down for me.

[Eskimo Brother]

I'm in the same situation, I own both. The sense I get around the boards is that if you're trying to win now, 1-2 year window, go with Rinne. He's on a bonafide playoff team with excellent D. If you can wait another year or two, go with the younger Andersen.

Those would be my thoughts, where it flips at that two year mark.

[Pengwin7]

Rinne for me.
I like the direction of Toronto... but for next 2-3 years I just think NAS is stronger team, especially the defense in front of the goalie.