URGENT - Arenado & Kluber for Goldschmidt & Sano

[Grand Slam]

I just got offered Goldschmidt & Sano for my Arenado & Kluber. I currently have Piscotty as my 1B but I can slot him at LF and move Grichuk at CF. My SP is also pretty solid.

Should I accept this offer?

Yahoo! 12 TEAMS - ROTO - 12 KEEPERs ONLY


(R), (HR), (RBI), (AVG), (OPS), (SB)

C D. Mesoraco
1B S. Piscotty
2B R. Odor
3B N. Arenado
SS T. Tulowitzki
LF R. Grichuk
CF J. Ellsbury
RF G. Polanco
Util N. Mazara
BN J. Schoop
BN A. Reed
NA T. Anderson


(K), (QS),(ERA), (WHIP), (SV) (HLD)

SP C. Sale
SP D. Price
SP K. Kluber
RP R. Osuna
RP L. Gregerson
P A. Vizcaino
P J. Jepsen
P T. May
BN C. Martinez
BN V. Valasquez
BN R. Iglesias
BN T. Watson

[STONE.]

Goldschmidt is an absolute stud, and although I'm still a Kluber believer (at least optimistic), I think you do well here.
Pitching is a bit flukier always.
Arenado is a tough loss, but Sano has all kinds of upside.

The downside is, if you're counting on Sano for 3B at future years, he won't have eligibility methinks.
Keeper?

If one-year, I like it.

[Eskimo Brother]

If you're okay with possibly losing third base options for future years, then it's a good deal.

[Grand Slam]

Thanks guy's for your feedback. It's been 1 week now and Kluber has now lost his first 3 starts and the other owner is still willing to trade Goldy and Sano for Arenado & Kluber.

Still not sure what to do and it's not a one-year league so makes it very hard to trade a 24 year old stud 3B that can hit 40+ dingers.

Any additional feedback would help once again. Thanks!

[Grand Slam]

96 views and only 2 feedback. Come on guy's, please leave some feedback if your visiting this forum.

[Eskimo Brother]

With the variability of pitching, I am definitely still doing that deal. Sano has the potential to get up to 90-95% of what Arenado does in the next couple of years, and if Colorado really starts selling and ships Arenado out of Coors, then you may be glad you got out early.