Reply With QuoteIt all depends on where Andersen ends up. If he ends up in Toronto, Gibson will be the better own. If he ends up in Dallas, Andersen will be. Pre-Deadline Gamble...
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
I prefer Gibson...but it's close!
Keeper's league, points only, 24 teams league Skaters: 1 pt for goal and 1 pt for assist, Goalie, 2 pts for win, + 2 pts for SO
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
It all depends on where Andersen ends up. If he ends up in Toronto, Gibson will be the better own. If he ends up in Dallas, Andersen will be. Pre-Deadline Gamble...
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
This is tough...Do you take the guy who is going to be the future of a solid playoff team for awhile, or the other guy who is going to stay a starter but on an unknown team...as much as I like Andersen I would have to say you go with the guy who has less variables attached to his future: Gibson.
NAHL - 16 Teams - H2H - pts based - 7F/4D/1G - 15 minors
DTDL - 30 Teams - H2H - multicat - nhl salary cap - 2C/2LW/2RW/4F/6D/1G/5B - 25 minors
BBRL - 20 Teams - H2H - multicat - nhl salary cap - 2C/2LW/2RW/4F/6D/1G/5B - 25 minors [Commish]
Vancouver Canucks of BBRL
C- O'Reilly, Stepan, E.Staal, Girgensons /// McCann, Eriksson Ek, Forsbacka Karlsson
LW- N.Foligno, Huberdeau, Martin, Lowry, Etem /// Vrana, Bertuzzi, Pollock
RW- Ryan, Forsberg, T.Wilson, Jaskin /// Rantanen, Guryanov, McNeill, Rod
D- OEL, Risto, Gudas, De Haan, Pesce, Davidson /// Werenski, Montour, Dunn, Forsling
G- Holtby, Varlamov, Johnson /// Grubauer, Makarov, Montembeault, Soderstrom
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
This has been a great little debate, seems like Gibson is the favorite, but only by a hair. It will be interesting to see what ANA does in the off-season. Thanks for all the input.
14 Team | Keep 5 | H2H Weekly Lock
Start: 2 x C, LW, RW | 4 x D | 1 x G
Scoring System:
+/- (0.5), G (3), A (2), PIM (0.25), PPG (1), PPA (1), SHG (2), ShG (1), BLK (0.1), HIT (0.1), GWG (1), HT (2)
W (5), SHO (3), S (0.2), GA (-1), ShSv (0.2)
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
I think Gibson is the guy to go with.
Contact me for Frozen Tools bug reports and inquiries
Follow Frozen Tools on Twitter @FrozenTools
Follow me on Twitter @DH_EricDaoust
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
In a playoff pool drafting right now, 9:43pm EST.
I've drafted Perry, Getzlaf, Kesler Vatanen.
With my eggs firmly in a basket, trying to decide between Gibson and Andersen if they remain available.
Who would you guys lean to for playoffs??
F: McDavid, Kucherov, Eichel, Gaudreau, M Tkachuk, E Lindholm, Rob Thomas, Hischier
D: S Jones, Werenski, DeAngelo, Hamilton
G: Husso, Raanta
*** ONE YEAR - POINTS ONLY *** skaters: 1pt/G, 1pt/A. goalies: 2pt/win, 2pt/SO *** 12 teams
MUST HAVE -- 8F, 4D, 2G --- (******Can only swap at same position, F, D, G ********)
10 ACQUISITIONS TOTAL ON THE YEAR (**I've used NINE of them - ONE LEFT**) *** NO BENCH - NO IR - NO TRADES BETWEEN MEMBERS ***
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
Drafts done. Never mind
F: McDavid, Kucherov, Eichel, Gaudreau, M Tkachuk, E Lindholm, Rob Thomas, Hischier
D: S Jones, Werenski, DeAngelo, Hamilton
G: Husso, Raanta
*** ONE YEAR - POINTS ONLY *** skaters: 1pt/G, 1pt/A. goalies: 2pt/win, 2pt/SO *** 12 teams
MUST HAVE -- 8F, 4D, 2G --- (******Can only swap at same position, F, D, G ********)
10 ACQUISITIONS TOTAL ON THE YEAR (**I've used NINE of them - ONE LEFT**) *** NO BENCH - NO IR - NO TRADES BETWEEN MEMBERS ***
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
What I think is that Andersen is the more consistent goalie, and Gibson is the more talented goalie. Gibson's best game is better than Andersen's best game, but Gibson's bad games are significantly worse than Andersen's bad games. Andersen is just steady. He rarely posts shutouts, but he rarely gives up bad goals. Gibson will play insane one night and then let in 4 softies the next night.
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
Tonight it's gonna be Andersen in net for Anaheim!
Keeper's league, points only, 24 teams league Skaters: 1 pt for goal and 1 pt for assist, Goalie, 2 pts for win, + 2 pts for SO
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
It's Anderson's opportunity to steal the crease to the finish line or bust.
KHL Fantasy Hockey League Keep 8
3-C 3-RW 3-LW 6-D 2-G
Forward 5-G 3-A 1.0 STP
D-Men 6-G 4-A 1.5 STP
.35 Shot .4 Hit .4 Block .1 FOW
Goalie 6.5 Win .25 Save -2.5 GA 2-SO
C- Larkin, Hischer, Horvat, R. Thomas
LW- Stamkos, Hyman, Kreider, Lehkonen,
RW- Laine, Marchessault, Toffoli. Buchnevich
D- Doughty, Burns, Letang, Andersson (IR), Faulk, Toews, Pionk, Petry
G- Vasilevskiy, Copley, Andersen
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
Gibson already has the 1 way contract. I don't see any way Andersen is in Anaheim next season.Originally Posted by wonko
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
The more I watch Andersen, the more impressed I am with him. Andersen is only about 3 years older than Gibson, so I'm starting to lean towards Andersen even if he gets traded. I think he'll be a great #1 wherever he goes.
14 Team | Keep 5 | H2H Weekly Lock
Start: 2 x C, LW, RW | 4 x D | 1 x G
Scoring System:
+/- (0.5), G (3), A (2), PIM (0.25), PPG (1), PPA (1), SHG (2), ShG (1), BLK (0.1), HIT (0.1), GWG (1), HT (2)
W (5), SHO (3), S (0.2), GA (-1), ShSv (0.2)
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
simply a show case. A team is going to pay handsomely to take this RFA off Anaheim's books. And Anaheim will continue to move forward with Gibson and (dare I say... Reimer!? hmmmmmm). Mark it.
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
Agreed. Welcome to Toronto Freddy! Here's your Offer Sheet.
You Too Mrazek!
Re: Who is the better goalie: Andersen or Gibson?
Riiiiight "simply a showcase". Because when a team is down 2-0 in a playoff series they're going to focus on showcasing a goalie for trade value..... if they win this series they could ride Andersen and who knows how far they'll go!
I love/hate this back and forth on these guys. I just hope the situation is more clear before I need to choose one next September!
16 Team Roto : Season 16 : Keep*5 : C,LW,RW, 4F, 3D, G, 4B, 2IR
G, A, PPP, SHP, +-, GW : W, SV%, SO
C: McDavid*
LW: Keller*
RW: Nylander*
F: MacKinnon*
D:
G: Shesterkin*
B:
*Keeper
Posting Permissions
