If you mean "CRAZY" as in it's true? Then I think I agree with you.
Hall has been out pointing Stamkos over the past 3 years (each of which had prolonged injury during that time and also the point of time we've seen Stamkos plateau and actually tail off and Hall continuing to progress).
2013 - 2016
Hall is averaging .92 points per game while Stamkos is averaging .89 points per game
Stamkos takes Hall on +/- (less so over the past 2 years) but this is largely a team stat and there is no comparison between these two teams.
Stamkos takes Hall PPP (hands down)
Hall takes Stamkos on PIM's if that stat counts for your league.
Opinions change on players as production changes for players. Until the past 2 years, while I liked Hall as a player more so, I never would have placed his value higher than Stamkos.
Now... I'm willing to bet that I could get Stamkos for Hall Straight up. A deal I'm not about to make as a Hall owner.