Trading for a keeper goalie

[slink]

I'm in a 12 team Yahoo rotisserie league with G, A, +/-, SOG, PPP, hits, W, GAA, SV%. We roster 21 players and get to keep 11 with a max of two goalies. Positions are 3 C, 3 LW, 3 RW, 5 D, 2 G and 5 bench. No salary cap or other limits to worry about other than keep 11, max 2 goalies.

Rinne is currently what I would consider my #1 goalie (Lack, Reimer and Domingue round out my roster) and frankly with my goalies I cannot compete in my league. I was considering moving Rinne and Getzlaf for one of the following goalies. How would you rank these goalies and at what point am I giving up to much for one of them? Rask and Fleury seem like a no-brainer to me but I don't know if Getzlaf/Rinne would be enough.

How would you rank them?

Tuukka Rask
Marc-Andre Fleury
Sergei Bobrovsky
Petr Mrazek
Jake Allen
Devan Dubnyk

[Triplea14]

dubnyk
rask
mrazek
fleury
allen
bob
this is taking into account keeping them for future years

[StuntMan12]

I'm in a 12 team Yahoo rotisserie league with G, A, +/-, SOG, PPP, hits, W, GAA, SV%. We roster 21 players and get to keep 11 with a max of two goalies. Positions are 3 C, 3 LW, 3 RW, 5 D, 2 G and 5 bench. No salary cap or other limits to worry about other than keep 11, max 2 goalies.

Rinne is currently what I would consider my #1 goalie (Lack, Reimer and Domingue round out my roster) and frankly with my goalies I cannot compete in my league. I was considering moving Rinne and Getzlaf for one of the following goalies. How would you rank these goalies and at what point am I giving up to much for one of them? Rask and Fleury seem like a no-brainer to me but I don't know if Getzlaf/Rinne would be enough.

How would you rank them?

Tuukka Rask
Marc-Andre Fleury
Sergei Bobrovsky
Petr Mrazek
Jake Allen
Devan Dubnyk

Rask
Allen
MAF
Dubnyk
Bob
Mrazek

[CHunter]

Rask
MAF
Mrazek
Dubnyk
Allen
Bob

[Dingy]

Mrazek
Allen
Dubnyk
MAF
Rask
Bob

[Bass56]

* Tier 1: Established starters that will be close-to-impossible to pry out of their owners' hands because they are stars and they are ''young''. I would avoid these unless their respective managers have them on the trading block.
- Tuukka Rask
- Marc-Andre Fleury

* Tier 2: Young goalies with great potential, but their asking price is going up quickly because they have been considered ''starters'' for most of the year and they have performed very well. The window is closing on these guys but this is the tier I would target.
- Petr Mrazek
- Jake Allen

* Tier 3: Established veterans that have had some great success but who have also had some very rough patches. Their asking price may be lower than the 2nd tier so they could end up being worthwhile (Dubnyk has had a good year so he will probably have a similar asking price to tier 2 or even tier 1... if so I would avoid him). Bobrovsky's value is at it's lowest IMO (injured and horrible season) so if you can get him for a little return, he might become a great steal in the long run!
- Devan Dubnyk
- Sergei Bobrovsky


Basically, it all depends on what you want to give, but if it was up to me, I would go for Mrazek or Allen while inquiring on Dubnyk's asking price.

[Crazy Joe Davola]

I'll be going against the grain here.. Long term value plus numbers?

Mrazek
Rask
MAF
Allen
Bob
Dubnyk

[M_Vandenbrand]

Mrazek
Allen
Rask
MAF
Dubnyk
Bobrovsky

Keeper league give me the younger guys, who's value is depressed by the fact they share playing time, despite being the better goalie. Mrazek >> Howard only reason why Howards still get's starts is his outrageous contract.
Allen will be given the keys to the Blues crease, if it wasn't for an injury he would be further away from the rest of this group.

Rask/Fleury coin flip at the third spot. Went with Rask because he's younger.
Dubnyk has been good this season, and is clearly the number one in Minnesota, though Minnesota sucks and can't score which hurt the W.
Bobrovsky was a favourite of mine for fantasy purposes a couple years ago, but can't avoid injury. I'd like to minimize risk when selecting keepers to ensure they get ample playing time. Though right now his value may be depressed the most.

You could probably land Mrazek straight up for Rinne, and if you wanted to still acquire another net minder, Getzlaf would be considered an overpayment for Allen so you may be able to weasel out a second piece or draft pick for Allen. Other wise he's probably a straight up deal for Rask.