Dubnyk vs Talbot

[forsbergfan]

duby vs Talbot - I know everyone will (and should) favor duby over Talbot, but is it close at all? Talbot has been lights out recently, and just signed a contract basically guaranteeing him the starter's job for the next few years. i'm wondering if I could get a real nice package of Talbot+ if I traded duby. I never want to compromise my goalies, so if it's not close at all, I wouldn't do it, but if Talbot is a good replacement for duby, then I think it would be worth it.
any thoughts?

[stefan17]

Who are your other goalies?

[forsbergfan]

Who are your other goalies?

holtby, luongo, hellebucyk.
it's a dynasty league, btw.

[jackalope]

I think you have some depth there in net to take a risk. But it would be a risk I think. So for me I would not be opposed to the swap,but it would entirely depend on the + coming with Talbot. Dubny is the better choice right now clearly.

[LawMan]

Give us your league scoring to help answer even more, in some league SV% and GAA are king, in others, starts and saves are King.

Agree with Jackalope. Dubnyk has proved more and, more importantly, is on a much better defensive team! If they were swapped Talbot might be better but they're not. Also, Dubnyk has no competition while Talbot has Nilsson short-term and equally importantly Broisette could challenge him in a year or two.

In sum, in a standard W/GAA/SV% type league I don't think its that close, until Talbot plays a whole season as a legit starter and the Oilers seriously beef up their defence Dubnyk is the much better option IMO.

Now you have a stud in Holtby, a steady guy in Luongo and an up and comer in Helly, if your skaters are hurting and you can get a big + for Dubynk then it may be worth it.

[havanablast21]

No need to,over think this.

Duby>Talbot.

[Zorro]

You can get much more then just Talbot for Dubnyk.. If your comparing the two then Dubnyk is the goalie you want..

[franklin]

You can get much more then just Talbot for Dubnyk.. If your comparing the two then Dubnyk is the goalie you want..

I'm with Zorro here. It should be: Dubnyk vs Talbot ++