Championship Check-over -- REP

[Zorro]

Would you guys keep A.Robinson (JAC) or J.Nelson (GB) if you had to pick just one?????????

[2014olympicgold]

Would you guys keep A.Robinson (JAC) or J.Nelson (GB) if you had to pick just one?????????

Wait till you see Nelson in the pre-season. With his age you don’t really know how he’s going to come back. He could be like Peterson or lose all cutting, stopping, and his speed ability. Prolly not the answer you wanted, but that’s my thinking.

If you had to set it right now, AR. Safer bet with keepers. It’s nice to have Nelson as a back-up plan if someone on your team gets hurt in pre-season too.

[Goldendelicious]

Would you guys keep A.Robinson (JAC) or J.Nelson (GB) if you had to pick just one?????????

What are the round implications (if any) of keeping one over the other?

I'm leaning Robinson here on my initial thinking. He's younger, Jacksonville is building a dynamic offense and he was lights out this year. His 14 touchdowns was tied for most in the league amongst receivers and in standard non-PPR scoring formats he ranked 4th overall at the position (behind only Brown, Julio and Marshall). Nelson's 2014 was better than Robinson's 2015 but I like where the Jags offense is going and Nelson is getting harder for me to trust next year. He will be will be 31, had back issues all last off-season causing concerns and then tore his ACL. I love Nelson, but I think I take the younger surging player in a keeper league.

[Zorro]

No draft pick implications whatsoever.. And it is a PPR league!!

I do have the benefit of being able to assess both guys through their respective training camps..

I have Brandon Marshall and Jarvis Landry too.. L.Bell is my one locked keeper thus far..

[Goldendelicious]

Right now, I go with Robinson...he doesn't see the same amount of targets as Nelson, but he is still a top endzone threat and establishing himself as a WR1 in the league. I just think Nelson has too much of a risk right now...but like you said training camp may tell a different tale.

[dejeanneret]

Would you guys keep A.Robinson (JAC) or J.Nelson (GB) if you had to pick just one?????????

I'd go with Robinson. Well on his way to superstar status and he helps guard your pool of keepers a tad against the inevitable approaching decline of an aging (but still dominant) Brandon Marshall.

[Zorro]

Thanks fellas, this definitely helps!!

[Goldendelicious]

For additionally input....Rotoworld just completed their 12-team mock dynasty draft. #1 off the board...OBJ

#2 was....wait for it....Allen Robinson! I was completely floored. The order of the first round kind of shocked me, especially with the RBs going at the end of the round (shows you how fantasy football is reshaping).

So next year, I have 4 guys that are considered 1st round dynasty draft picks....needless to say, I've pushing my commish to expand the keeper list from 3 to 4

Here's the article in case you haven't seen:
http://www.rotoworld.com/articles/nf...sty-mock-draft