Offer on the Table,should I pull the Trigger?

[mr coffee]

Ok, Eberle & Monahan for my T.Rask!

I know many of you don't like me trading Rask at this time (Buy-Low Candidate) but managers in this dynasty put a very low value on Goalies! Which I don't understand because they account for @44% of our scoring!

And the managers in this league seldom if ever Trade! Unless its a one-sided deal (to them of course). So based on this info,do I take the deal? My best,other offer was M.Stone & J.Neal for T.Rask.


Thanks in advance,I need your advice!


Cheers

[Doug Glatt]

Can you get someone better than Eberle? In a multi-cat he's not that great.

[mr coffee]

I get you point,but hard to find RW's in this league,and as I said these managers are tight! lol

I did just get another offer Vanek,Neal & Seabrook for Rask. He also has M.Stone who was in original offer. So maybe another combo of the 4

Or is Monahan,Eberle a better deal in dynasty?

[Doug Glatt]

These offers smack of quantity not quality. It's Rask, dont be hasty.

[havanablast21]

These offers smack of quantity not quality. It's Rask, dont be hasty.

Agreed. Just cause the other GM's undervalue goalies didn't mean you need too. I'm not much of a fan of this return for Rask in your league.

[mr coffee]

Would a counter of Monahan,Erberle,& Draisaitl for T.Rask be out of line? Is it enough for Rask?

[Sulla]

Personally if it accounts for 44% why would you even want to trade Rask?

[als_revenge]

Even if your concern is that Rask doesn't fit the age structure of your team (which is debatable), I'm not sure why you need to trade him right now? Boston had an awful start, but are putting things together. Presumably you can get a little more just by waiting. Is there a reason you are so keen on moving him asap?

[mr coffee]

Wow,thanks for bringing me back to reality! lol. You are correct,I don't really need to trade Rask,I think I just got caught up in the negotiation game ;-)
I will hang on and continue to learn from Dobber's Army!

Man,I love this site!

Thanks to all you guys,cheers!

[Zorro]

Keep Rask my friend, unless you get a deal you love.. You clearly don't love these offers or you wouldn't be questioning them..

You should stock pile goalies if guys don't think they are valuable.. Grab'em all!!

[mr coffee]

Took your advice Zorro and picked up Hellebuyck,had a room on bench to stash him.

Got another offer from a different manager, Giroux for my Holtby Finally a decent offer,but I'm not interested in moving Holtby.

Would a counter of F.Andersen for Giroux be out of line? Or would you offer F.Andersen for one of the other 2 offers I received above?

I appreciate the advice to HOLD my goalies,but I think I have a Trade Bug! lol. I'm thinking if I hold Holtby/Rask/Allen/Vasilevskiy/Hellebuyck,I'm solid for sometime!

And try an improve my wingers with trading F.Andersen,make good sense?

[als_revenge]

Andersen will not get you Giroux, IMO. He's currently out (short-term), but more importantly, ANA is an absolute mess so far this year. And there is the John Gibson factor. People will not pay a premium for a goalie that is perceived to have question marks re: long-term starter status.

How many goalies do you start, and do you have daily or weekly changes? 4 starting goalies + Vasilevsky & Hellebuyck does seem excessive.

[mr coffee]

I agree,I don't see Giroux for Andersen deal happening either.And I realize his value is down now,but I expect ANA to get things going soon I hope! And I'm also banking that when Gibson gets the keys,that Andersen goes elsewhere and starts! I believe he is a RFA at the end of this season? So what can I expect to get from F.Andersen

We start 2 goalies per day,minimum of 3 starts per week. Scoring- W,L,GAA,SV%.

[mr coffee]

Would my J.Allen for his Giroux be a fair counter? He has Elliott on his bench,so what do you think?