DT+K.Williams for Amari+Gurley/Lewis

[NJDev803]

12-team .5ppr league. This guy keeps proposing trades trying to get one of my RBs (most recently Karlos Williams) for Peyton Manning and/or Spiller, and I keep turning them down. But looking at his roster, Amari Cooper, Todd Gurley, and Dion Lewis are some guys I wouldn't mind having.

Is the price of Demaryius + Williams/Miller/Hillman too steep for Cooper + Gurley/Lewis? Worth noting it's a 2-keeper Auction draft league.

My Full team:
Dalton, Bradford
L.Murray, Miller, K.Williams, Hillman, David Johnson
DT, Julio, Landry, Stevie Johnson, Dorial Green-Beckham
Kelce

His team
Brady, Peyton
DeMarco, Spiller, Lewis, Gurley, R.Mathews
Cobb, A.Cooper, Moncrief, Garcon, Jordy
Clay


I like my team, despite the lack of a consistent RB2, but I'm currently 1-3 after unlucky matchups. I currently have the most points for and against in my league, which is why I'm a little hesitant to make any drastic changes.

That said, I still need to start winning soon. And with Miller/Landry on bye this week, and Williams possibly out with a concussion, I'm looking at starting Hillman as an RB2 this week if I don't make any deal. Lewis has had his bye and could be serviceable the rest of the way as the Pats pass-catching back. Gurley has a tough schedule and a bye next week, but pretty good keeper-potential.

[Bomm Bastic]

First, if you move DT you target Gurley and only Gurley as the RB in return. You do not move DT for Lewis despite his recent success. Given that it's a two keeper/auction, I place higher value on plug-n-play RBs since they are a more scarce commodity than WRs. If you can move DT + Miller for Cooper + Gurley, do it.

[mwojt21]

First, if you move DT you target Gurley and only Gurley as the RB in return. You do not move DT for Lewis despite his recent success. Given that it's a two keeper/auction, I place higher value on plug-n-play RBs since they are a more scarce commodity than WRs. If you can move DT + Miller for Cooper + Gurley, do it.

I agree with this--don't do the deal for anything less than Cooper + Gurley. Personally, I'd try to see if you can move K Williams (obsolete when McCoy comes back) or Hillman (RBBC w Anderson on a team that doesn't run well) over Miller. I still think Miami is too talented to be this bad--its just a dumpster fire from a management standpoint--and their schedule has been pretty bad thus far. Just my 2 cents.