Goalie Tiers

[karljans]

Last year there was a really helpful thread started by Pengwin I believe that broke down the goalies into tiers that was continuously updated based on votes/comments
I wonder if we can do something like that again

[rainydrinkwater]

Ya. That was a good thread. Surprised it hadn't been brought up yet. Surprised I forgot about it.

[Pengwin7]

Thanks.
I have one somewhere in the last month or so... mercy, I miss the search function used to work better.
If we could search my posts of last two months and search "TIER" we'd find it.

Aha!
I found it:


Paste version:
Here is my own personal order of goalies for this season:

The 18: #1 Goalies
Tier I (3): Price(MON), Holtby(WAS), Lundqvist(NYR)
Tier II (10): Rinne(NAS), Bishop(TB), Quick(LA), Rask(BOS), Andersen(ANA), Dubnyk(MIN), Crawford(CHI), Fleury(PIT), Bobrovsky(CBJ), Schneider(NJ)
Tier III (6): Halak(NYI), Luongo(FLA), Varlamov(COL) Anderson(OTT), S.Mason(PHI), Miller(VAN)
19 NHL Teams Covered

The "Six-n-Six": 1a/1b TimeShareQuestionMarks
Tier IIIa (12): Niemi/Lehtonen(DAL), Elliott/Allen(STL), Howard/Mrazek(DET), Hiller/Ramo(CGY), M.Jones/Stalock(SJ), Pavelec/Hutchinson(WPG)
6 NHL Teams Covered

The 2: Big Maybes that Could Steal Time
Tier IIIb: Vasilevskiy (TB), Andrew Hammond (OTT)

The 4: #1 Goalies on DisasterDefenses
Tier IV: Talbot(EDM), Bernier(TOR), M.Smith(ARI), Lehner(BUF)
4 NHL Teams Covered

The YuckShare: Carolina
Tier V: Cam Ward & Eddie Lack
1 NHL Team Covered

[PenguinHunter]

Thanks.
I have one somewhere in the last month or so... mercy, I miss the search function used to work better.
If we could search my posts of last two months and search "TIER" we'd find it.

Aha!
I found it:


Paste version:
Here is my own personal order of goalies for this season:

The 18: #1 Goalies
Tier I (3): Price(MON), Holtby(WAS), Lundqvist(NYR)
Tier II (10): Rinne(NAS), Bishop(TB), Quick(LA), Rask(BOS), Andersen(ANA), Dubnyk(MIN), Crawford(CHI), Fleury(PIT), Bobrovsky(CBJ), Schneider(NJ)
Tier III (6): Halak(NYI), Luongo(FLA), Varlamov(COL) Anderson(OTT), S.Mason(PHI), Miller(VAN)
19 NHL Teams Covered

The "Six-n-Six": 1a/1b TimeShareQuestionMarks
Tier IIIa (12): Niemi/Lehtonen(DAL), Elliott/Allen(STL), Howard/Mrazek(DET), Hiller/Ramo(CGY), M.Jones/Stalock(SJ), Pavelec/Hutchinson(WPG)
6 NHL Teams Covered

The 2: Big Maybes that Could Steal Time
Tier IIIb: Vasilevskiy (TB), Andrew Hammond (OTT)

The 4: #1 Goalies on DisasterDefenses
Tier IV: Talbot(EDM), Bernier(TOR), M.Smith(ARI), Lehner(BUF)
4 NHL Teams Covered

The YuckShare: Carolina
Tier V: Cam Ward & Eddie Lack
1 NHL Team Covered

Should almost start a new thread with this and name it the same as last year... using 2015-16?

[Pengwin7]

Good idea.
I'll do that later, just started a Yahoo! mock during my lunch.

[karljans]

Good idea.
I'll do that later, just started a Yahoo! mock during my lunch.

You are the man!