Malkin Perry Kopitar sell all?

[PSlipps]

12 team, keep 15 plus Farm, H2H, 12F 6D 2G 6Bench
G A P PPP SOG PIM W SV% GAA

Im in a mini rebuild. Have McDavid plus several young studs on my prospect team.

Knowing little, would you move Malkin, Perry, Kopitar (my last established studs who helped me win)
for... Mackinnon, Johansen, Forsberg, Palat, and the 8th pick this draft (Provorov or Barzal).

Im looking to win in 2 years. My prospect core is McD, Gaudreau, R Strome, Duchene, Ehlers, Vatanen, Klingberg, Mantha, A Lee, Fiala.

Malkin and those 2 are my last solid stars left, is that big trade worth it or try and get more?

[ericdaoust]

Keep what you have. It's not like Geno and Perry are about to retire.

[Nikerato]

Definitely do not do that.

Those three players are elite and have 5 years of consistent production left in them.

In a keep 15, I wouldn't even consider keeping any of the players you listed - besides McD - over them. Besides, it looks like you need some room to keep a goalie or two, and some more D. Either way you slice it, that return is not good enough.

[Slug]

I would want more. That trade won't have you in a better spot 2 years from now.

[sergioel]

MacKinnon could replace Perry production in 2 years. Same for Johansen with Kopitar. That leaves Forsberg Palat and the 8th for Malkin. No way jose.

[Dennis4022]

Try a buy low and offer Kopitar for MacKinnon. I would even add a piece if that makes it happen.