Deadline Deal - Need Help

[Chico Resch]

Thanks for all of your help Dobberites...

My team is in 2nd...Good, but no great. Details below.

Im going to trade Hutchinson. Whats the best deal?

Marleau and Neilsen

or

Scheifele and Hertl

Marleau and Neilsen are the best for now....
Scheifele and Hertl are (I feel) big studs in the next year or two

Marleau is depreciating and Neilson gives good hits and blocked shots, but - what am I getting out of these guys? My gut says option #1, because of win now, but are they still productive enough to warrant ignoring the youth and upside of option #2?

Thanks in advance.

[Dobber]

I would take the 'win now' option. Tough to turn your back on Scheifele though. If you have zero shot at first, then I'd say Option 2

[Chico Resch]

Thanks Dobber. Any other takers? Bump!