Pick and Tweak my Keepers!!

[0PucksGiven]

Hey Dobber family

Just curious on who you think my keepers will be in both of my leagues (in sig)?

I know its a lot of work but i will rep when i can and i appreciate the insight.

would you change any in either league?

Team 1 is a keep 8 (contending)

Team 2 is a keep 10 (rebuild)

[0PucksGiven]

Bump

[Oakville Squires]

For team one the only change that I would make would be to replace Tarasenko with Shattenkirk as I think Shatty's production would be harder to replace through the draft. I might also consider keeping Holtby over Schneider given that the Devils are at the beginning of a rebuild that will negatively affect Schneider's wins over the next couple years.

For team two your keepers look good and I wouldn't make any changes.

[Big Baby]

C: Seguin, Giroux, Stamkos, Soderberg, K. Hayes
LW: Benn, Steen, Hartnell, Huberdeau
RW: Voracek, Tarasenko, Ryan, Zuccarello
D: Hedman, Shattenkirk, Chara, Myers, Timonen, Rielly
G: Schneider, Holtby


C: MacKinnon, Johanson, Stepan
LW: Hall, Drouin, Gaudreau, Kreider
RW: Wheeler, Okposo, Zuccarello
D: Carlson,Vatanen,Trouba,Timonen, Ceci
G: Bishop, Gibson, Smith

[Xavier LaFlamme]

Team 1: Seguin, Giroux, Stamkos, Benn, Voracek, Tarasenko, Shattenkirk, Holtby.

I would monitor the situation closely on Hedman for the rest of the season. It's somewhat mind boggling that he's receiving no time on the power play, but I can't imagine that lasts for long, especially now that Yzerman has beefed up the teams defensive depth. With that said, Shatty is lights out on the PP for the Blues, and if I were picking my keepers now, I'd probably lean towards him with your cats.

Team 2: Mack, Johansen, Hall, Drouin, Gaudreau, Wheeler, Okposo, Carlson, Bishop, Gibson

My worry with Vatanen is that Wiz is going to cut into his power-play time. If you can keep two goalies, I think it's a good idea to hold onto Gibson here. Even if he doesn't take on his fair share of starts next season (which I believe he will), he's great trade bait. Also, Gaudreau over Stepan all day everyday.

Good Luck!

[The Good Sir]

Team one looks solid, only change I might make would be Holtby over Schneider.

As far as Team 2 goes, I'd replace Stepan with Gaudreau and Vatanen with Gibson. Everything else looks good

[Laendarian]

Team 1 I also like Holtby over Schneider, although it would be nice to find a way to keep both (or maybe package two keepers for an upgrade)

Team 2 it would be nice to find a way to keep Trouba or Gaudreau but they don't bump any of the guys you high-lighted in my opinion

[Wizzy33]

Team 1 - Holtby over Schneider however I wouldn't be happy about letting him or Shattenkirk "walk" and would look for a 2 for 1 upgrade.

Team 2 - I might keep Gibson over Vatanen since its a rebuild.

[0PucksGiven]

Thanks. I will try to consolidate talent on both teams.

Any other opinions guys! Rep when I am allowed to again today