Possible Getzlaf deal...

[GoNucks]

What side would you prefer...is this a fair return?

Kucherov & Scheifele & Stralman

Or

Getzlaf

[horrorfan]

In a vacuum, Getzlaf without hesitation. If I had Getzlaf and received that offer, I would reject that instantly.

[vmascarello]

What side would you prefer...is this a fair return?

Kucherov & Scheifele & Stralman

Or

Getzlaf

In smaller leagues like 12 teamers, I always like to get the best player in a deal. So, I would keep Getzlaf despite recieving some real good young players. But, there's no guarantee either become 70% of what Getzlaf is right now.

[Top_Shelf]

Good post above...in a 12 team Getzlaf for sure...I'd actually still take Getzlaf even it was a 16 team league.

[newper114]

yeah getz myself here. if you are going for the win getz for sure if your rebuilding go with someone a lot more elite. for me I just traded getz and my return was Drouin and a top 12 pick in 2015 entry draft.

just to give context. while the guys your getting will be good players they wont be elite.

[philly_fan]

I want getzlaf.

[jcairns]

Yeah, same as others. I quite prefer the Getzlaf side. Even in 5 years Getzlaf will still be the best producer out of all the other parts in that deal.

[ericdaoust]

Even in deeper leagues there are better ways to fill the depth than downgrading a star. Getzlaf for me.

[GoNucks]

Okay thanks all, I will up my offer for Getz!