Would anyone accept this trade

[dirtybirdy]

I got offered in a keeper league malkin, galchenyuk, nyquist and siedenberg for ryan johansen, Hall, and Gudas.
League counts G, A, P, PPP, -/+, Hits, blocks , PIM

[RookieInsider]

DON'T
RyJo + Hall better then Malkin + Gally.
Gudas is a walking PIM producer that hits like a truck that you just can't find in other players

[Pengwin7]

It depends on how many you start at each position.

Value-wise:

# Malkin
...
. @ Hall
. @ Ry-Jo
...
# Nyquist
# Galchenyuk
...
. @ Gudas


Roster allocation determines a player's relative value, which is key in these trades.

For example, just using points, let's assume waiver wire forward is 50pts.

Malkin 90, +40
Nyquist 60, +10
Gally 60, +10

vs.

Hall 80, +30
Johanson 80, +30
...


That's just considering the forwards... just points.
Multi-cat, stuff gets really complicated - but it's the same math... determining how far a guy is better than waiver players.

The deeper the league, the more those end guys have value.
In shallower leagues, Malkin holds the most value by far, than Ry-Jo and Hall... and the other my have minimal value.

In general, I like to get my Hits/BLK/PIM from waiver defensemen.
So not knowing more about your league, I'd say Malkin/Galchenyuk/Nyquist is my preferred side (and... people overlook it... but that side's +/- is going to dominate Ry-Jo Hall)

[SeaDawg]

I'd make that deal.

I'm a big believer in Malkin, and Nyquist has looked incredible.

To me, Malkin/Nyquist is more valuable than Hall/Johansen.

Then it is Galchenyuk and Seidenberg for Gudas, which I think is also an improvement for you.

[2014olympicgold]

Malkin 69 games 79points (+29)
Nyquist 80 games 63 points (+13)
Gally 79games 58 points (+8)
+50


Hall 72 games 80 points (+30)
Johansen 77 games 70 points (+20)
Gudas 76 games 30 points (average d 30pts? So +0)
+50

If you have the IR spot to hold Malkin when he’s hurt I’d take the Malkin side. If you have an IR+ you most definitely should take it. If you have an injury riddled team, I’d stay with Hall. You can only have so many people on an IR before it gets into a burden. Also when Malkin is hot, you could flip him for a really good player. AKA Kane, Kessel, Tavares, Subban (big in this format), Karlsson, Seguin +, Benn +, or Backstrom +

[SeaDawg]

Malkin 69 games 79points (+29)
Nyquist 80 games 63 points (+13)
Gally 79games 58 points (+8)
+50


Hall 72 games 80 points (+30)
Johansen 77 games 70 points (+20)
Gudas 76 games 30 points (average d 30pts? So +0)
+50

If you have the IR spot to hold Malkin when he’s hurt I’d take the Malkin side. If you have an IR+ you most definitely should take it. If you have an injury riddled team, I’d stay with Hall. You can only have so many people on an IR before it gets into a burden. Also when Malkin is hot, you could flip him for a really good player. AKA Kane, Kessel, Tavares, Subban (big in this format), Karlsson, Seguin +, Benn +, or Backstrom +

what are the numbers in brackets for? +30, +29, etc.

NM...figured out after looking at Penqwin's bloody complicated post again...between all the # @ symbols and comparing Malkin to a waiver wire forward for some reason, I completely lost his train of thought in that post.

Also, Hall and Malkin are about equal when it comes to injury-risk.

[junyab]

This would be a tough one for me...and because of that, I'd stick with what you have.