Duchene/Galchenyuk for Doughty/Kreider

[KeepnitReal]

Thoughts?

I am still looking to move Galchenyuk and this offer came accross my table.

What do you guys think?

[Kofax]

Doughty's not a bad defenseman to own in your league, but Duchene remains the best player in the deal. I would pass on this offer.

[Laendarian]

Pass for me, prefer Duchene to Doughty and Gally to Kreider

[rainydrinkwater]

I'd rather have douche and galch.

[mounD]

If that category is "Hat Tricks" and not "HiTs," then definitely Duchene side. If the category is Hits, then this deal gets a bit more interesting. Might have to side with Doughty/Kreider, as Doughty is a top5-6 Dman with those settings and Kreider could be the next multi-cat stud. I might roll the dice with Doughty/Kreider honestly -- with the proviso that if the category is Hat Tricks, you stick with what you've got.

[KeepnitReal]

yeah that catagory is Hits... I'll fig my sig, thanks for noticing cause I had no clue

Also thanks for the feedback so far.

[Fast Tony DeNiro]

Keep Duchene and Gally. Having hits as a cat obviously helps the Doughty/Kreider side, but hits are much easier to find from other sources. Duchene and Gally will give you higher point totals and those are harder to find.

[pmorrow]

Keep duchene. Those two guys are good but I feel hits shouldn't be overvalued given how easy it is to get guys who hit in the later rounds. Duchene has 90 point upside in the near future IMO. I think he's amongst the bright young stars like Hall and Seguin in terms of talent but just hasn't got there yet

[Irriducibile11]

Whoa no, don't do that.

Even as a Kings fan I'm telling you that Doughty is not THAT valuable in fantasy league. And Kreider isn't even worth one third of Duchene.

[robmyatt]

Pass for me, prefer Duchene to Doughty and Gally to Kreider

absolutely.
seems to be a strong consensus on this one.

[KeepnitReal]

Thanks guys!

I am a habs fan and love galchenyuk. So making that trade would have been difficult. I guess my desire to have a top end defensman was blinding me lol and yes I consider Doughty as an elite defensman, prob top 20 at the very least.

I will pass, and look elswhere for a defensman, will probably cost me because people in my league are mega stingy when it comes to trades.

Someone one wanted duchene for eller!! lol and got offended when I said they were mental

[royal_pain]

I would keep Duchene & Galchenyuk. Ducnene is already the best player here and Galchenyuk could have a break out season.