Shultz, Trouba, Carlson, Rielly or Hamilton?

[Yeahboy]

Hi guys,

Points only league.

I need to invest in a new young D-man. Who will put more points in the next 3-4 years?

IMO
Shultz, 45-55
Rielly, 45-50
Trouba, 45
Hamilton, 40-45

Make sens?

[rainydrinkwater]

I think Rielly has the best offensive potential.

[mounD]

Trouba for the next 2 years, then I'd expect Rielly to overtake him. Ultimately, because of the short-term benefit (and long-term upside being comparable) I would prefer Trouba here.

[havanablast21]

Carlson made your title but not your projection.

I'd rank'm

Rielly
Carlson
Shultz
Trouba
Hamilton

[RizzeeDizzee]

Go back and dig up my Cage Match articles on Trouba and Carlson, as both have limited points ceilings because of how important they are to their team, including shorthanded. For points only, I actually like Hamilton as he looked like he took a big leap toward the end of last season.

[wendelclark17]

Rielly might not be the best short-term option but he has the highest upside of that group in a points only league so I would go with him. He has 50+ pt potential in my opinion.

[forsbergfan]

hamilton, and then hamilton. next on the list - hamilton. and after that - hamilton. get him now. this is gonna be HUGE breakout season. future norris trophy winner. gonna be one of the best in the league. trouba is in a tier below him, and the rest won't be elite.

[havanablast21]

hamilton, and then hamilton. next on the list - hamilton. and after that - hamilton. get him now. this is gonna be HUGE breakout season. future norris trophy winner. gonna be one of the best in the league. trouba is in a tier below him, and the rest won't be elite.

I wouldn't trade my Rielly for Hamilton. Hamilton will be great... I don't see him as elite. But clearly no convincing you. Lol

[Neverender9]

I like Rielly long-term, but I like Hamilton sooner. Trouba could hit 40 this year, but is better suited for multi-cat leagues.

[Magicstew]

Reilly for me too, multi cat I may go with Trouba.

[Dakkster]

Points only, I like them like this:

Hamilton
Schultz
Rielly
Trouba
Carlson

[sharpp87]

Points only, I like them like this:

Hamilton
Schultz
Rielly
Trouba
Carlson

I own all of them except Hamilton and I would rank them like you...I just dont know where to put Hamilton...

The only I'd trade for Hamilton would be Carlson..otherwise I like them more or same....so Place Hamilton where you want and for the rest I like this order

[Hockey6723]

Shultz: oil will get better. Soon.
Carlson: pp!
hamilton: not sold yet