Help ranking my (top) prospects

[Irriducibile11]

Hey everyone, in my keeper league we'll soon have our annual prospect draft: 10 teams, 3 rounds. Goals (G), Assists (A), Plus/Minus (+/-), Powerplay Points (PPP), Shorthanded Points (SHP), Shots on Goal (SOG), Faceoffs Won (FW), Hits (HIT), Blocks (BLK).
We do NOT count PIM.

I have obviously my own ranking, but if you have some time to spare I'd appreciate if you could rank them according to your opinion - too much input never hurts.

I'm looking for pure long-term fantasy upside more than for short-term help or anything else.

I always rank them by position (so e.g. 1.Draisaitl, 2.Bennett ... 1.Mantha, 2.Dal Colle ... 1.Kapanen ... etc etc - I do NOT make a huge ranking of all of them together (e.g. 1.Draisaitl, 2.Mantha, 3.Allen .... 50.Milano). Please don't do that).
In this thread they're sorted alphabetically (i.e. what you see below is not my ranking). And they're only the top prospects - I have more on my list but with only 3 rounds, I'll probably never get to draft them anyway (unless their value skyrockets next year). Obviously, if you feel like someone not on the list should be included, feel free to do so.


C
Bennett
Draisaitl
Fabbri
Nylander
Petan
Reinhart
Schmaltz
Wennberg
_________________

LW
Burakowsky
Dal Colle
Ehlers
Fiala
Gaudreau
Mantha
Milano
Perlini
Pulkkinen
N.Ritchie
Scherbak
Virtanen
_________________

RW
Goldobin
Ho-Sang
Kapanen
Kucherov
Pastrnak
B.Ritchie
Tuch
Vrana
_________________

D
Beaulieu
Clendening
De Angelo
Dumba
Ekblad
Gormley
Honka
Morrissey
Morrow
Pulock
Theodore
Vatanen
_________________

G
Allen
Demko
Husso
Jarry
Makarov
Martin
McDonald
Nedeljkovic
Stolarz
Visentin


Thanks a lot!

[Dobber]

This is a big thread and I had only wanted to jump in just for a few minutes and answer a question or two. I think if you split this up into six 'ranking' questions (by position) then you'd get a lot more answers. Just keep in mind for the future

[Irriducibile11]

You are right. Unfortunately, I only thought of this after having created the thread. Sorry, my bad.

Actually, the thread can be deleted (I cannot do it), it's a waste of space. Thank you.



PS: Actually, it is split into five questions. I don't expect anyone to rank these players into one huge ranking, that would be nuts. I don't do that either, it's useless. What I meant was rank them within their position.
So for example:
1.Draisaitl
2.Bennett
3.Reinhart
etc

1.Dal Colle
2.Mantha
3.Ehlers
etc

...

1.Allen
2.Visentin
etc


I just re-read my post and I see that I never specified that. So it was definetely unclear for a reader what I wanted. Sorry!

[Fast Tony DeNiro]

Alright, lemme give it a try....

C
Bennett
Draisaitl
Reinhart
Nylander
Wennberg
Fabbri
Petan
Schmaltz
_________________

LW
Dal Colle
Ehlers
Mantha
Gaudreau
N.Ritchie
Burakovsky
Fiala
Scherbak
Virtanen
Milano
Perlini
Pulkkinen
_________________

RW
Kucherov
Kapanen
Vrana
Ho-Sang
Goldobin
Pastrnak
B.Ritchie
Tuch
_________________

D
Ekblad
Morrissey
Vatanen
Clendening
Pulock
Theodore
Honka
Dumba
Beaulieu
Gormley
De Angelo
Morrow
_________________

G
Allen
Jarry
Demko
Nedeljkovic
Visentin
Makarov
Husso
Martin
McDonald
Stolarz

Defense and goalie were tough....I'm not 100% happy with the ranking on defense especially, so many players were almost identical in value to me. But ya, there's a quick ranking. One question.....you say we can suggest adding players. So is someone like Andrei Vasilevskiy already taken? Or Drouin? I'm assuming yes, but I'd be interested to know what kind of other players might be available.

[Irriducibile11]

One question.....you say we can suggest adding players. So is someone like Andrei Vasilevskiy already taken? Or Drouin? I'm assuming yes, but I'd be interested to know what kind of other players might be available.

Yeah sorry, I didn't make that clear either... Yes, both are taken. Generally you can assume that all top prospects from previous years (such as Drouin, Vasilevsky, Teravainen, Strome, Nurse, Pouliot, Strome etc etc) have been drafted. The next best players on this list would be guys like McCann, Rychel, Armia, Barberio, Gillies etc... Those type of players.