Donovan vs Barberio vs Vatanen

[Bender]

In a Dynasty league who would you rather own and why?

20 H2H Dynasty: G/A/+-/PIM/PPP/SHP/SOG/HTS/BLK

[Zorro]

Well I am the 7th person to vote and the 1st to post something.. Not sure why people vote and don't post??

I would love to have Vatanan out of these three dmen.. I think he is going to have a very nice future in Anaheim going forward..

Donovan has a good shot putting up some points with the Islanders.. Barberio has some competition in TB to overcome..

[Noddes55]

I'd like Donovan because of the multicat points he will produce, plus if the islanders keep taking steps forward they could be a decent team soon. I do really like vatanen as well, but I'd prefer the multicat player

[Bender]

Thank you for your responses Zorro and Noddes. Overall it looks like Barberio is the odd man out here. The guy has a lot of potential but agreed he is a little below the other two.

[Axeman33]

I also voted Donovan. I like Vatanen and it was hard because I felt Vatanen took some nice steps forward this past year, while Donovan almost seemed to stay stagnant as far as his progression goes.

I have been high on Donovan for some time now and I hope he takes the next step this year. Vatanen is going to be an offensive player but Donovan has a chance to be a better multi-cat type player.

[Ed.]

I like Donovan, but I do worry that he has a couple of first rounders and a second rounder nipping at his heels, in Reinhart, De Haan and Mayfield. I hope he carves out his niche soon.

[Magicstew]

Vatanen is my pick - he is getting accustomed to NA hockey and is in a pretty good situation in Anaheim.

[27Blue]

Vatanen.
He is in the NHL to stay...
and QBing the Ducks PP is a pretty good gig.

Donovan still has a ways to go to prove he belongs in the big leagues...

[Dobber]

Vatanen seems most like a sure thing and his upside is the highest. Vatanen all the way

[ridethesnow]

Vatanen because islanders will strangle donovans chances of greatness and barberio hasnt proven much at the top level.

[reeveta]

Not sure why people vote and don't post??

A vote provides an opinion. A post requires an informed opinion which is a lot more work.

[Rad64]

I also like Vatanen, situation and timing favors him for an early return. The Ducks should be even better next season with another year under their youngsters belt.

[Laendarian]

Vatanen for me, he's already in a top 4 role and has very little competition for PP time. Donovan is probably better for multi-cat purposes, which I actually usually like to load up on with defence, but in this case Vatanens offensive upside and more established position edges it for me.