Choose 1 keeper.

[PR Parrots]

Choose 1 keeper.

League details below.

Sergei Bobrovsky
Corey Schneider

I am having trouble with this one. Bobrovsky with another solid season. This one should cement him as a legit goalie. I am always a little weary of the Blue Jackets though. Their history has been one filled with lots of shortcomings. Can I trust them to keep this playoff caliber play for several years to come?

On the other end... Schneider is a solid goalie playing for a Defensively sound franchise. His W was pitiful given lack of offense despite his solid numbers. With Brodeur getting older.. And maybe retiring this year? His starting role could be solidified. I guess this one will also depend if he stays in NJ. I have a feeling if Schneider stays in NJ and they improve their offense, he could be one of the top goalies in the league.

What say you?

Thanks!

[Magicstew]

Got both for next season, but if I had to decide I would go with Bob. It would also be easier to redraft Schneider - for your above reasons.

[Grapes]

Schneider for me

[Axeman33]

I like the direction that Columbus is headed. Owning a Vezina in his young career doesnt hurt either.

Bobrovsky for me

[woodrow]

Tough choice for sure. I'd probably lean towards Bobrovsky because he is younger, he has no one challenging him for his job and I like the way Columbus is growing as a young team. You really can't go wrong with Schneider either I think, but I like Bob a little better myself.

[Bubba55]

Bob for me. Pretty impressive track record so far and the Jackets are looking good for the future. Schneider is more of a question mark, certainly looks good, but he has simply not accomplished what Bob has, I prefer fact not speculation.

[LedgerSko]

I'd go with Bob. He has a little better track record right now. There is still the Marty factor. Who knows exactly how that will play out, and Schneider might be easier to get in a redraft, Bobrovsky, not so much

[lucifer316]

Bob for me quite easily

[PR Parrots]

Thanks guys. You have convinced me. I agree Bob will go way sooner in next year's draft in comparison to Schneider. I may be able to redraft Schneider although there is always a goalie frenzy on the first round of the draft each year. We shall see if he is available. I think ill keep Bob. Thanks!

[PR Parrots]

Thanks guys. You have convinced me. I agree Bob will go way sooner in next year's draft in comparison to Schneider. I may be able to redraft Schneider although there is always a goalie frenzy on the first round of the draft each year. We shall see if he is available. I think ill keep Bob. Thanks!

I'd like to revisit this thread as Schneider has been re-signed long term and looks to be the clear #1 in NJ. Everyone still think Bobrovsky is the real deal and that I should trust the Blue jackets moving forward?

[Axeman33]

I'd like to revisit this thread as Schneider has been re-signed long term and looks to be the clear #1 in NJ. Everyone still think Bobrovsky is the real deal and that I should trust the Blue jackets moving forward?

Well I fully expected Schneider to re-sign with NJ and take over the reins there when I replied the first time.

I'm still on the Bobrovsky train.

[MarmotKing]

I'd like to revisit this thread as Schneider has been re-signed long term and looks to be the clear #1 in NJ. Everyone still think Bobrovsky is the real deal and that I should trust the Blue jackets moving forward?

Both are good goalies. I would probably still go with Bobrovsky, but Schneider is a close second imo.

[Kofax]

Are you able to trade one? Trade whoever gives you the best return, keep the other. Both are excellent options going forward. Bobrovsky will likely get you more wins though.

[petegreg21]

I'd go with Bob at this point. Both are undisputed starters and blah blah blah, I just like Bob a whole lot better.

[Savvy1982]

Both good goalies - Bob will see a few more shots, and have roughly the same SV%. - so he should be a better bet in your format.