Seguin or Kessel!? (Keep 4)

[I'm byfuglien]

Decent Idea. I could probably trade Subban -- he has a lot of value. I'm picking 6th overall in a keep 4. Byfuglien was available this year.

[jcairns]

I align with most others on here. I own Seguin and would not trade him for Kessel, precisely for the reason dobber stated. I think both will consistently be at a ppg, but Seguin will have some boom years and could hit 90+

[blayze]

I've always been a big fan of Seguin and I'm glad to see him finally realizing his enormous potential in Dallas.

Having said that, I'll still take the guy who's finished top 6 in scoring the last 3 years in a row - especially in a goal-weighted league (yes I do realize Seguin has only 1 less goal this year).

[27Blue]

Seguin for me. Just scratching the surface...

[jcairns]

I've always been a big fan of Seguin and I'm glad to see him finally realizing his enormous potential in Dallas.

Having said that, I'll still take the guy who's finished top 6 in scoring the last 3 years in a row - especially in a goal-weighted league (yes I do realize Seguin has only 1 less goal this year).

I see them as a wash for goals. As you mentioned, Seguin has only 1 less, and has played in 2 fewer games. They both have sustainable shooting percentages in the 12% range. So I wouldn't really worry about that. Given Seguin's age, and upside, I easily take him, but I definitely understand your reasoning for the safe, consistent bet.

[suvojitde]

I would look to keep both especially if I can get Subban OR another decent point scoring D in the draft (Hedman, AP, Yandle, Giordano).

Re: a question you had in one of your other posts, I don't think anyone trades Stamkos straight up for either Kessel and Seguin, but P Kane may be a different story.