Seguin / Suter for Parise / Kesler

[davestorey]

Thoughts on this trade? I would be the one getting Seguin. I am about 20 pts out of first, other owner is done but needs another keeper (we keep 7). Giving up too much for the future? (15 team in sig)

[Mr. Guru]

I'd take that deal.

[lucifer316]

that is an extremely easy yes

even if i needed an extra keeper if i were out of it in a league there is no way in hell i would be trading away Seguin for Parise and Kesler

that is just brutal imo

[MillerTime89]

Call me nuts but I'd rather have the Parise/Kesler side. I'm just not a fan of Suter in fantasy. Yes, Seguin is awesome, but both Kesler and Parise put up decent numbers too.

[Mr. Guru]

I'm a fan of any defender playing 27 min a night.

Points by default.

[MillerTime89]

I'm a fan of any defender playing 27 min a night.

Points by default.

So you'd roster Brian Campbell and Justin Faulk just because they play over 20+ minutes a game? TOI doesn't always translate into being an effective fantasy hockey player. Real-life, yes, Suter is a BA, but in fantasy hockey, unless TOI is a category, he really doesn't do that much.

[lucifer316]

Seguin/Suter - 147
Parise/Kesler - 141.25

that is about where i figure the numbers for both pairs

only one player in either grouping is going to be a keeper and Seguin's 92 far outpaces the 75.75 of Kesler or the 65.5 of Parise

looks to be a win now and in the future to me

[brakli]

I'd make that deal. Best player (Seguin) and a defenseman who will quarterback a good power play unit.

[Mr. Guru]

You realize Suter is a top 15 defender?

- - - Updated - - -

So you'd roster Brian Campbell and Justin Faulk just because they play over 20+ minutes a game? TOI doesn't always translate into being an effective fantasy hockey player. Real-life, yes, Suter is a BA, but in fantasy hockey, unless TOI is a category, he really doesn't do that much.

I'd roster them over a lot of guys. Yes.

[davestorey]

Lots of good feedback....

Here is how I got here:

He offered me Seguin for Tavares and Gallagher/Suter for Kesler/Edler (he wants Kesler as a keeper)

This is my counter

[lucifer316]

he isn't taking that counter

he was trying to buy low on Tavares he has no interest in selling you Seguin

[Shake]

Sign me up for the Seguin / Suter side.

[Darren_Kennedy]

Really like this deal. In a pool where you only keep 7 having top end talent is so key (as opposed to a more balanced, overall lineup). Seguin looks like a top 15 guy moving forward - Kesler has a lot of questions, and while Parise is great he probably tops out at 65-70 points and 290ish shots in MIN.