Trade Offers

[Deuces6]

Team in Sig

One Gm wants Hedman and Nichushkin from me for Buff and Killorn

The other Gm wants my Anaheim line Perry/Getz/Bonino for Pavalski/Johansson/Perron/Anisimov/Markstrom

We carry 15 forwards and one goalie from our roster into a separate playoff pool when playoffs start.

Should I be considering either, or walking away and stay put? I have some good draft picks for our rookie draft this summer, Johansen and Monahan pretty much locked down, plus some good free agents available. The second trade frees up some cap for me and gives me some extra bodies, I'm one forward over the roster minimum.

[StaveOffElimination]

Definitely not the Anaheim offer, not even close to value for Perry and Getz. I like the Byfuglien offer, it's tough to give away Nich but you are getting the best player there. Maybe try to get a pick thrown into that deal.

[bizzl]

The Anaheim offer isn't good at all. Stay clear of that one. The other one is much closer. Depends on whether you think Hedman can keep developing. If yes, then I stick with Hedman and Nichushkin (no question Nichushkin>Killorn). If no, then go for Buff. I'd lean towards keeping Hedman and Nichushkin though.

[rataylor22]

As said. God. That Anaheim deal is laughably bad. Bonino is the 4th best player in that deal. Just decline and I wouldn't even entertain follow up offers from that GM.

The first deal isn't bad, but I'm on the same side as Bizzl. I think Nichu is an absolute stud, especially on that line with Benn and Seguin (I think Dallas is gonna keep that line together for the next 5 years, it's so dominant). It's a pretty fair offer, but I don't think it is a clear win, and I'd rather keep what you have. Hedman seems to really be stepping it up and is gonna grab more PP time next season on an improving young team. I think Buff will hold stead at the production we've seen the last couple years (but not see any improvement) and Killorn just isn't on the same level as Nichu. Killorn is gonna get passed over by Drouin, Kucherov, Namestnikov, Palat, etc.

[Deuces6]

Thanks all! I was kinda feeling the same way, but just wanted validate my train of thought. I get overwhelmed when multiple offers get thrown around, especially when I am in last this year, everyone thinks that they can poach my team for nothing essentially!