Results 1 to 5 of 5

Thread: Kane, Seguin, Pietrangelo, OEL, can't decide

  1. #1
    Grapes's Avatar
    Grapes is offline
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    in the fairway
    Rep Power

    Dobber Sports Apprentice

    Question Kane, Seguin, Pietrangelo, OEL, can't decide

    I have over analyzed to the point I can't make a decision, need help.

    Have been after P.Kane for awhile now. Other G/M willing to talk if Giroux or Seguin is included.
    We have also talked about OEL & Pietrangelo.

    Do I go back with Pietrangelo & Seguin for OEL & P.Kane
    or do I offer Pietrangelo & Giroux for OEL & Kane

    Keep 6 daily starts

    Much appreciated, thanks
    2011-2012 , 2013-2014 League Champion
    Keep 6 - 18 roster - 10 Teams
    2C, 2RW, 2LW, 4D, 2G, 1utility, 5 bench, 2 I/R

    C: Crosby, Backstrom, Giroux, Eichel, Thornton, T.Johnson
    RW: P.Kane, Perry
    LW: Hall, Martin
    D: Hedman, Letang, Klingberg, Gudas, Ghost
    G: Holtby, Andersen,Gibson
    I/R: Streit

    Roto scoring cats:
    Skaters: (G)(A)(HITS)(PPP)(SOG)(+/-)(DEF-PTS)
    Goalies: (W)(SV)(GAA)(SV%)

  2. #2
    NS, Canada
    Rep Power

    Dobber Sports Star


    I am not convinced you win either trade. Nor does the other GM. Seems a wash either way. All the guys involved play top line minutes, top PP minutes, earn similar numbers of PIM, get similar SOG. My only tipping point may be that both Seguin and Giroux are currently on weaker teams than Kane, but over time that could level out.
    If you want to shake things up for the sake of shaking things up and your love for Kane, logic dictates that Giroux is an elite player and that you gotta let Seguin go.
    20-team, points only. G: 2-W, 4-SO.
    Top 9F, 4D & 1G . Keep 15, Carry 20
    F: Stamkos, MacKinnon, Stepan, Yakupov, Scheifele, Nichushkin, Marner, McCann, J.T. Miller, Hansen, Stempniak
    D: Ekblad, Barrie, DeAngelo, Severson, Orlov, Demers
    G: F. Andersen, Gibson, Vasilevskiy

    Let The Right Muzzin; RHRS
    C:Bergeron, Desharnais, Couturier, J.T. Miller
    LW: Landeskog, Toffoli, Saad, Huberdeau
    RW: Tarasenko, Oshie, Pominville, Seguin
    D: Shattenkirk, Hamilton, Muzzin, Gudbranson, Holden, Spurgeon
    G: Bishop, Talbot
    Bench: Hammond, Berra, Stempniak, Cizikas

  3. #3
    Rep Power

    Dobber Sports Prodigy


    I like the Seguin option better - still very unproven at this point. I also like OEL better long-term than Pietrangelo.
    12 team league
    G, A, STPts, +/-, PIMs, GAA, S%, W
    Start 12 fwds, 7 d, 3 g; keep full starting roster + 3 on farm
    (Salary cap = 1200)

    F: Malkin(55) Perry(75) Hall(125) Stepan(20) Wheeler(20) Ott(35) Okposo(50) Hertl(15) Lecavalier(120) Jagr(10) Strome(25) Drouin(55) MacKinnon(55) Couturier(10) E.Lindholm(20) Arcobello(20)
    D: Weber(65) Keith(40) Hedman(105) Gudas(10) Bieksa(55) Larsson(70) Ellis(25) Orlov(20) jSchultz(30) B.Smith(40)
    G: Rinne(40) Markstrom(25) Enroth(35) Khudobin(30) Greiss(15) Hutton(20) Stalock(10)

  4. #4
    Rep Power

    Dobber Sports Novice


    Agree with The Bottlenecker...feels like you're forcing the move.

    I had all these guys (inc Giroux) on my team last year actually.

    If you're dealing even numbers and not condensing talent, I expect you're not planning to change your keeper plans based on this deal, or aren't worried about it one way or the I'm not going to get into that.

    What I think you'd look to do is Seguin+Pietrangelo for Kane+OEL. I think Seguin's potential is about where Kane is at already. Pietrangelo and OEL are each a different kind of consistently productive d. Both can score, but you'll fill more categories more regularly with Piets. You give up that benefit by grabbing a more known quantity on an elite offensive club in Kane. The upside is that I believe OEL has the ability to put up points in the 65+ range and coming from the backline that's a great benefit.

  5. #5
    Rep Power

    Dobber Sports Veteran


    Quote Originally Posted by Grapes View Post
    Do I go back with Pietrangelo & Seguin for OEL & P.Kane
    or do I offer Pietrangelo & Giroux for OEL & Kane

    Keep 6 daily starts

    Much appreciated, thanks
    If I was a Kane/OEL owner, i'm not sure I'd make either of those deals. Piets and OEL are about even, and I'd rather have Kane over either Seguin or Giroux. Gun to my head, i'd move Giroux and Piets for OEL and Kane and see how that flies.
    Points only keeper League, 24 teams, weekly head to head, 2RW, 2LW, 2C, 4D, 1 G , (goalies 2pts for W +3 for SO) [/I][/B]
    Keep 11

    LW: Gaudreau, Huberdeau, Kreider, Boedker

    C: Seguin, MacKinnon, Ennis, Scheifle, Teravainen

    RW: Ryan, Eberle, Dano, Jagr

    D: Klingberg, Ekman-Larsson, TJ Brodie, Niskanen, Dumba, Ceci, Zadorov

    G: Halak, Mason

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts