6 player trade + picks

[jcairns]

Who do you prefer in this: G, A, +/-, SHP, Shots, Hits, Blocks

Looking at this year and next year (win now mode)

Bobby Ryan, Eberle, Carlson, Round 3 pick

or

Nash, Perry, Dillon, Round 4 pick

EDIT: New trade

Ryan, Eberle, Ladd, Carlson

for

Nash, Perry, Clowe, Faulk

[lorenzin]

hmmm... this is a fairly close trade, however, if it is for a win now type thing, the NASH/PERRY side as they are more proven then Eberle and Ryan. Again, I say that with this being very close, although the defence side Carlson over Dillon but BD could surprise some people.

[Mattp913]

Rick Nash gives you the best chance of winning now. Go with his side. He is by far the best player in the deal. And Perry will give you shots + hits in addition to solid point production.

[jcairns]

Rick Nash gives you the best chance of winning now. Go with his side. He is by far the best player in the deal. And Perry will give you shots + hits in addition to solid point production.

Perry should match Ryan for points, and Ryan will hit more. So really it just comes down to the others in my opinion. I'm erring on your side, though.

[Mattp913]

Perry should match Ryan for points, and Ryan will hit more. So really it just comes down to the others in my opinion. I'm erring on your side, though.

Good thinking. I think we will see a new Rick Nash this year under Alain Vigneault. IMO he is a LOCK for 80+ points and has an upside of 90+. His trade value will be significantly higher soon if you are patient. Not that I'd necessarily recommend trading him when that value is higher. He is definitely your second best forward after Stamkos.

[jcairns]

Got him to add in Ladd for Clowe. So the new trade is:

Ryan, Eberle, Ladd, Carlson

for

Nash, Perry, Clowe, Faulk