Neal, Pietrangelo, 2nd for Seguin, Perry, 3rd

[jcairns]

His Neal, Pietrangelo, 2nd round pick

for

My Seguin, Perry, 3rd round pick

League stats are in signature. Keep in mind, we don't count PIMs (which is where Perry holds a lot of his value). A 2nd round pick in my league (after keeper picks), would land a 55 point player, or someone a bit higher who either had an off season last year or injury woes (ie. Skinner, Hartnell, etc). It is possible goalies might also go in the 2nd round, as it's a keep 8 league (8 teams in league) and most teams will only be keeping one goalie.

[jcairns]

Any thoughts from anyone? I'm thinking this is a pretty solid offer, or at least something to counter from.

[mr_long1990]

I think I like the Neal side if PIMs is not a category in your league. It's pretty close though IMO.

[HockeyProphet]

I don't like this trade for you. I would prefer to keep Seguin and Perry.

[Scorgasm]

I like Neal's age and situation over Perry. I think points will be fairly equal. If you had a second defenceman worth keeping you would probably do so and have to drop another forward. I'm not sure how many you dress every week but I've always found that having solid D is key. A one-two of Letang and Pietrangelo plus your solid crop of forwards would be a good start. With that said...

Seguin is still a POTENTIAL player. He could skyrocket this year or still be immature...he is a big question mark. Maybe less spotlight in Dallas will help him. I think you could still get more...maybe up the pick if possible.

Tough call though

[Mattp913]

Scoop that trade up. Neal is by far the best player in the deal and you are getting a great young defenseman. I'd definitely do it.