Duchene-Seguin-Kopitar-Toews?

[JHouly]

Keeper's League, points only (G=1, A=1)
Who should I Keep? I must keep two of them.
Duchene-Seguin-Kopitar-Toews?
Rank them please.
Thanks!

[franklin]

It's really close between Kopitar, Toews and Duchene.

But I'd go with Toews and Kopitar.

[Carcillo]

1. Toews
2. Kopitar
3. Duchene
4. Seguin

I'd keep Toews and Kopitar.

[HockeyProphet]

Toews
Kopitar
Seguin
Duchene

Toews and Kopi have the bigger names, which would likely fetch you more in trade too! Could change after a season but..

[CT-Chill]

Toews
Kopitar
Seguin
Duchene

Toews and Kopitar are the most consistent among the 4 and in a league in which assists are just as valuable as goals, Kopitar has a huge edge above Seguin and Duchene. I'm also a huge Kopi homer so I would take him over Toews but in reality its likely very close. I do think Kopi's ceiling is the highest amongst the 4 however.

[ericdaoust]

Toews
Kopitar
Seguin
Duchene

Toews and Kopi have the bigger names, which would likely fetch you more in trade too! Could change after a season but..

This list.

[lucifer316]

toews and kopitar are about even here and both are ahead of duchene and seguin

[3rtpaper]

Tough call.. Seguin is definitely last on this list for me...

I would probably go with Toews or Kopitar.. if you want to be safe.. but I would definitely wait until the offseason if you can. Chicago will lose a slew and the Kings.. well it really depends on what happens to them in the playoffs I think. If Niemi shuts the door on them again they might look to trade for another top 6 guy which would help Kopitar out a lot, making him the clear pick.

As for Duchene.. he is really the wild card of the bunch. He put up 43 points in 47 this year (better than Kopitar). I really feel that Duchene's season wasn't noticed by many because of how bad Colorado was this year. He could very easily be the highest scorer of the bunch going forward. I really do feel he will be a great value pick in all drafts next year.

[dodospice]

Well this is my list:

1- Jonathan Toews, the kid really can play and put up points with the best of them a PPG player at the minimum.
2- Anze Kopitar, he should be about a PPG also much like Toews only difference is Chicago scores more and I see Toews as having the higher upside.
3- Matt Duchene, probably a 70ish point player right now with the potential to be a ppg so to lose points now and not get substantially more points then Toews or Kopitar in the future just isn't worth it.
4- Tyler Seguin, has a very high potential but with Boston being a score by committee type team I don't see him scoring as many points as everyone else but his upside is very high as everyone knows.

[wendelclark17]

Kopitar
Toews
Duchene
Seguin

[fungchen3]

1. Toews
2. Kopitar
3. Duchene
4. Seguin

I'd keep Toews and Kopitar.

I concur. Exactly how I would rank them as well. I would flirt with listing Kopitar as the top dog but the Kings spread it out.

[TheZamboniGuy]

Toews / Kopitar
Duchene
Seguin

[JHouly]

It'a gonne be a tough choice...
I still don't know wich one to go with for the future...

[fungchen3]

It'a gonne be a tough choice...
I still don't know wich one to go with for the future...

Did you decide yet? I would rule out Seguin right off the bat. Young kid, real nice talent, but he should not be considered the top option with players like Toews, Kopitar and Duchene on the board. Toews should be connected to the hip with Kane for a long time and they are one of the most dynamic duos in the NHL. Kopitar is Kopitar - big, smooth, great all-around, potential to hit 85-90. Duchene is a young stud but the Avs need to improve A LOT before he starts putting up a steady shot of PPG numbers. I think Toews is your guy.

[JHouly]

I guess it's gonna come down to which players will give me the best return possible in a trade...
But I think I'm gonna trying the best I can to keep Duchene and Toews...