Who to keep: Seguin, Eberle, Duchene or...

[Meniac]

So most of us are at that stage where we know if we're going to have a chance to win our leagues this year. Unfortunately, I will not. So I need to determine who my keepers are and whether or not I should upgrade and sell while I still can.

We're allowed to keep 4 and so far I have Malkin, Backstrom and Kopitar. I originally was planning on keeping Seguin as my fourth, but lately I'm not so sure. To be honest, I haven't been a huge fan of his, but it seems like most people are. I see Seguin's upside in a league that includes +/- and shots, but I'm in just a regular G and A league (1 point for each). I see his skill when I watch him play, but playing on a team where the scoring is so spread out and on what seems more like a shut down line with Bergeron and Marchand has me concerned that Seguin will have problems pushing the PPG mark.

Would I be crazy to trade him for someone like Eberle, Duchene or Kovalchuk? All of those 3 are a possibility, but am I selling short on Seguin? Who has the most potential for points next season?

[joeb323]

Points only I think it's a tough call. Personally I think all three of Seguin, Eberle, and Duchene are 80-90 potential players, so it's probably a wash going for one of the others. But, if you're not a fan of Seguin personally I don't see it hurting you swapping for Eberle or Duchene.