Better Dynasty Keeper?

[Dbacks]

Adam Eaton......Tyler Skaggs.....or Wade Miley?

[MikeTSchmidt]

Skaggs is the pick here. We are talking about a pitcher who is blessed with both considerable upside and polish. Don't let his underwhelming performance in six starts following his promotion to the big leagues (5.83 ERA, 6 homers allowed in 29 1/3 innings). He has the upside of a No. 2 starter (think Madison Bumgarner).

This is nothing against Eaton, who is a high-energy player who could see considerable playing time the Arizona outfield in 2013. He's a useful speed guy with 10-homer ability, but his ceiling is far from that of Skaggs.

Miley is a bona-fide MLB hurler, but I expect his numbers to see some serious regression in 2013. He doesn't strike out a ton of batters, and I'd be really surprised if he's able to match his BB/9 of 1.71 from a year ago. Ultimately, he's a replaceable fantasy pitcher.

[dmvincent]

Welcome to the boards!

I'm going to take Miley here, but only for the short term. Miley was a top prospect coming up in his own right and we can't just forget the season he had last year. Eaton is due to get regular playing time and does a lot of things well.

In short, here's how I rank them.

Long term

Skaggs
Miley
Eaton

Short term

Miley
Eaton
Skaggs

[unlisted]

I think Skaggs by a lot. Much better pedigree and pitch repertoire