Seguin vs Skinner?

[Ari Gold]

Just kind of curious where everyone ranks these 2 players. Both out of the same draft, 2nd overall vs 7th overall. Both have shown they have the potential to dominate so now... Who would you rather have for:

1) This Year
2) 3 Years

[dejeanneret]

I've not voted yet since I'm debating whether Skinner might get the edge this year. But even if he does, it won't be by much and long-term I'd take Seguin hands down (and have been a Skinner owner since day 1).

[Essej]

Misplaced my vote, but for me it's Seguin now, and Seguin future.

[Ari Gold]

Pardon my ignorance but trying to figure out what the difference is for them in terms of upside..

I think Skinner has about 80pt potential while Seguin I am not sure. Is Seguin's upside another 20 points?