Thats tough one. It seems like a decent trade. Your D would get a significant upgrade and you still have Malkin, Tavares, etc. If you honestly dont feel Ovie will even be himself again, which at times doesnt look likely, id consider the trade. I think youd might be able to get somekne younger than Chara, but he still has great production for a dman.
Im in a similar position owning Ovechkin in a cap league at $9 and that contract expiring at the end of this season. Its a tough decision.
5th Year Dynasty - 12 Teams
Positions: 3C, 6W, 6D, 1UTIL, 2G, 7BN
C: Giroux, Datsyuk, M. Koivu, McDonald(IR), Couture, Stepan, Gerbe
W: Ryan, Lucic, Vanek, Voracek, Malone, E.Kane, Okposo, Stewart, Michalek
D: Pronger, Keith, Karlsson, Hedman, Giordano, Fowler
G: Brodeur, Rinne, Crawford, Schneider
Prospects: Beach, H.Karlsson, Tangradi, Baertschi, Hackett, Salak, Elliot, MacLean