H. Sedin, Wheeler, Hiller for Bryz, Kovy

[AwesomeSince86]

League in sig

Which side would you rather have? I'm thinking of making this offer due to the goalie situation in ANA mixed with the possible buy low on Kovy. Any chance this even gets accepted? I'm thinking it might be a reach.

[LawMan]

I think its a very balanced offer to make. I like it for your team ever so slightly.

Kovalchuk has the higher upside and is better in your scoring format but Hank is far more consistent and although he's not lighting it up he has put up the steady, A, PPA and +/- you'd expect. Edge to Kovalchuk.
Wheeler is not a throw in by any means, he's the real deal and I expect him to be just under a point a game this year. Edge to Hank + Wheeler over Kovy.

Bryzgalov is rounding into where I'd expect him to be and he'll consistently get the starts in Philly, Hiller could start to lose more starts to Fasth in a hurry which in a league that counts 3 of 5 positive cumulative goalie stats is big. Hiller has absolutely no trade value right now and has to get better than he's been only because he's been soo bad.

Depending on what you could get back as the 3rd skater (he'll have to drop regardless), or what's on the wire I think this trade just tips in your favour.

[AwesomeSince86]

It seems like everyone here is as divided on this as I am. To be honest, my biggest concern is that Wheeler explodes for big points this year. If it helps the decision process, my pickup for the FA list would probably be Brunner. He is playing on the top line and getting consistent pts along with a decent amount of shots. Does that help sway the decision one way or another?

[AwesomeSince86]

Another option I am considering is offering:

H.Sedin + Hiller for Semin + Rask

Again, banking on the Sedin name to help even up the trade. Not sure if this one gets accepted.

[AwesomeSince86]

bump

So far this is pretty even. Anybody wanna help me swing this one way or the other?

[PittPens1787]

Another option I am considering is offering:

H.Sedin + Hiller for Semin + Rask

Again, banking on the Sedin name to help even up the trade. Not sure if this one gets accepted.

I was just today offered Hank Sedin and Hiller for my Rask in a league similar to yours minus the PPG and SHP. I considered it then turned it down. No way Im giving up a stud goaltender in a league with five goalie cats for what at this point is just Hank. Hiller doesn't have a job right now.

If you can pull this off you win IMO