Should I accept?

[legendkiller89]

1 year league team in sig

MY: St. Louis and Couture

for

HIS: Giroux and B. Richards

I'm leaning towards accepting but want some feedback

[lucifer316]

i am not sure i understand the question

[legendkiller89]

I was offered this trade, wanted to see if you guys would accept or not?

[9601]

I was offered this trade, wanted to see if you guys would accept or not?

Take it, laugh, then run.

[lucifer316]

personally i wouldnt take it

[Jenken]

Take it, laugh, then run.

Disagree. Couture could very well outpoint both those guys in a 1 year league. Even if he doesn't, this is far from a "laugh and run."

Anyway, Pretty sure you posted this same question a couple days ago and I said I'd take the Couture side. I stand by that.

[9601]

Disagree. Couture could very well outpoint both those guys in a 1 year league. Even if he doesn't, this is far from a "laugh and run."

Anyway, Pretty sure you posted this same question a couple days ago and I said I'd take the Couture side. I stand by that.

Serves me right for not seeing what section this was in. I clicked the link from the main site.
I still like the Giroux side, but its much closer when its a one year league. St. Louis is very reliable and plays with Stamkos, Couture is Couture and is off to a great start. Giroux can get points by himself, but it certainly hurts that Hartnell is out for so long and their wingers are going down like flies.

[havanablast21]

This is a kick ass offer. I LOVE offers that make you read...re-read and then review again...start your answer, change your mind and rethink the whole thing.

I think Couture is something special...and while there is a chance (as someone already mentioned) that he may out point either of these guys, I don't think he will out point both. Giroux is top 3 material along with Crosby and Malkin and STamkos. Couture has the ability to be 1 tier down IMO...still with ELITE company (Tavares, Hall, Seguin, RNH and much like older guys Thornton and St.Louis and Iggy used to be in their prime.

While I think Coutour may hold more value than Richards, I don't think he touches Giroux. And St.louis is also = Richards at best.

IMO

Best player hands down (NOW AND FOR THE NEXT 5 to 7 years)
Giroux
.
.
Couture
.
Richards
.
St. Louis (age alone for limited keeper as they both are playing with all star linemates.)

I'd Take Giroux and Richards and be feel fairly confident.

[DaymanFighterOfTheNiteman]

I personally like the St. Louis/Couture side.

TB and SJ put up serious goals.
PHI (this year so far) and NYR, not so much.

That's what I'm basing it on. And Giroux goes from having Hartnell and Jagr on his wings to nobody. That hurts the bottom line.

[forumname]

I think Marty will out-point Giroux this year, and I think Couture will outpoint Richards, so there's my answer.

[tomastop]

another one for MSL and Couture side!