Neal + Yandle for Ovechkin + Phaneuf ?

[LeTrefle]

Points only. Keep 6. No positions.
Last week, I asked if Neal was in the same tier of Ovechkin when comparing players.
Results were surprisingly in favor of Neal in the replies and greatly in favor of Ovie in the poll.
This week, Ovechkin owner made an offer to me.
His Ovechkin + Phaneuf
My Neal + Yandle
I believe that Ovechkin worths more than Neal, but Yandle vs Phaneuf makes me thinking about this trade.
Do I pull the trigger and count Malkin, Stamkos and Ovechkin on my squad?
Do I decline and look my opponent trying to sell desperatly a declining Ovie around the league?

[gainerama]

The upside will definitely be with Ovi but i think the consistency might stick with Neal and friends. This is probably a lateral move this year. If you need to get on base, stick with Neal. If you already have good hitters and want to swing for the home run, go with Ovi. The defence is a wash.

[Essej]

If you want to take a risk take Ovechkin, if you want to play it safe stick with what you got. Personally I like Ovechkin too much, to not take the risk. Keeping Neal has a higher precentage to work in your favour in my opinion.

[LeTrefle]

I didn't accept his offer yet.
He took it off the table, wanting to see if he could get Tavares or Giroux offering Ovie.
I think he got turn down.
So, do I go to him and re-offer the same deal?
I think it would be great to have Stamkos, Malkin and Ovechkin on the same keep-6 team.
Input?