D keith for D backes

[Hockey]

Straight up. in a 12 team head to head counting G, A, +/-, PPP, SOG, Hits, Blks. Rosters are as follows: 3 or each forward position, 6 dmen, 2 goalies, 7 bench.

What do you guys think? which side would need to add more? and how much more?

Thanks for any answers

[andrewklassen]

Both are pretty solid multi-cat producers. Both eat up solid PP minutes and overall ice time. Both are under-achieving to start the season [like many others].

I'd actually consider these 2 pretty even except you run 9 F to 6 D and that ratio makes contributing D extremely valuable and harder to obtain that F. With this in mind I prefer Keith.