Giroux v. Marleau

[Furbz]

hey guys -

The Flyers are currently having a bad start and so is Giroux. Would it be a good time to try to get him ?

Is Marleau a good trade for Giroux?


Think I could start with something like Giroux/Byfuglien for Marleau/Souray ?

[Jenken]

Hell no, you lose both parts of that deal. Keep Giroux and wait it out

[blayze]

That's a horrible trade.

Buy low sell high... not the other way around.

edit: nvm, I read the response above mine and assumed you were the one dealing Giroux. In either case, that's an insulting offer haha

[forumname]

I don't think many people would give you Giroux alone for those 2 guys. Adding Buff kills it, but I guess it never hurts to try. If he's insulted, so what.

[Slaxys]

agreed, Giroux side is so much better

[Furbz]

Just in case I wasn't clear, I have Marleau and wondering if I could get a nice trade of his hot start

I think I'm going to try the Giroux trade, there's no way Marleau can keep it up right lol

[Jenken]

Okay you just totally reworded your question, lol.

Worth a shot but it won't happen, especially with Buff in there

[Slaxys]

well then it's a huge steal if you can get this deal, though I doubt it

[Furbz]

think I'm going to try 2 trades with 2 different players

Marleau/(Seabrook or Giordano or Souray) vs Giroux/Burns

Marleau/(Seabrook or Giordano or Souray) vs Perry/(Goligoski or Wiz)
be a better fair trade?

what do you guys think?
ty