RW trades options

[QStar]

15 team h2h league
goals, assists, pts, +/-, PIM, PPP, SOG, Wins, Saves, GAA
starting rosters: 4LW, 4C, 4RW, 6D, 2G + 6 bench
My team:
C: Krejci, Stepan, Stastny, Henrique, Cammalleri C/LW
LW: Lucic, Clowe, Perron, Conacher, Sullivan
RW: C.Stewart, Parenteau, Brunner, Frattin, Wellwood C/RW
D: Chara, Pietrangelo, MDZ, OEL, Leopold, Methot, Vlasic
G: Rinne, Varlamov, Gigeure, Mason

1) I have an offer of RW Horton for my LW Clowe. I prefer Clowe to Horton, but given positional needs, the deal makes sense.

2) I was also offered RW Burrows + LW S.Kostitsyn for LW Conacher + C Stastny

3) I am considering an offer of RW Horton + C/RW Gagner + C/LW Tlusty + D Mcbain for LW Clowe + LW Sullivan + C/RW Wellwood + D MDZ (or OEL)

Thoughts on these three offers?

[Gaborlick]

I would take offer three. If you are getting Horton and Gagner, you win. especially since Gagner actually plays center. This guy must really want Clowe, only the whole San Jose being amazing thing will sputter out.

The other deals are bad for you.

[4T2]

#1 - Fair value swap, you don't win this trade outright other than the fact that it fills positional needs.

#2 - Not a bad deal if Burrows turns it around and Conacher slows down, but tough to make right now with Conacher playing so well. Kostitsyn is not looking impressive yet. If you can upgrade Kostitsyn to a better LW, I would be more comfortable.

#3 - I don't like this deal for you at all. Especially if involves OEL.

[QStar]

An update:

The last offer was changed to:

RW Horton + C/RW Gagner + RW Kassian + D Goligoski + C/LW Tlusty

for

LW Clowe + C Stastny + RW Frattin + D OEL + LW Sullivan

[Gaborlick]

An update:

The last offer was changed to:

RW Horton + C/RW Gagner + RW Kassian + D Goligoski + C/LW Tlusty

for

LW Clowe + C Stastny + RW Frattin + D OEL + LW Sullivan

I like it. Maybe I am bias because Gagner has a point in every game this season and Horton is starting to heat up. I'm not a fan of Clowe and Stastny isn't producing. Frattin has been pretty sick though.