From reading everyones posts I guess I will be in the minority but with all those peripherals, I am taking Weber.
You guys can all play your "gut" but I am going with the numbers. You would have to go back 3 years to find a season where Doughty out-performs Weber with those peripherals, and that was only because of Doughtys amazing offensive season.
I am going with the guy who "should" have won the Norris trophy last year. Give me Shea Weber.