Benn or Eberle?

[kevin_mcallister]

Points only keeper, Benn or Eberle? and go....

[Call of Doughty]

EBERLE for me. Anyone who knows me, knows i'll pump Eberle's tires anyday of the week. Massive supporter of this kid. I would take Benn in a heartbeat, but he's up against #14 here. I think Eberle has a slighty higher ceiling and should be a consistent 84-92 point player in his prime. Benn, 78-84 point player. Not too shabby for each. Both current and future stud wingers. Eberle's support cast just makes me drool....

[Essej]

Benn for me. Can't go wrong with either one of them.

[ericdaoust]

Both are awesome but I think Eberle is a class above.

[Shake]

Eberle for me. That PP will become lethal. Even strength they may be about equal but I personally feel the PP is what separates Eberle.

[Fast Tony DeNiro]

I've been skeptical of Eberle, and I'm still not ready to go all-in with him. But the more I see the more I'm coming around, there's just something special about him as a player. And you can't argue with his supporting cast in Edmonton.....it's Eberle for me.

[MXHockey]

Eberle for all the reasons stated, but the gap isn't that big.

Cheers.

[arctic_rogue]

I'm a bit down on Eberle, but in a pts only, I would take him. Talent wise, he's on par with Benn IMO, but with a much better surrounding cast.

[Axeman33]

Points only, Eberle for me.

[Stan Smyl]

Benn, for me, but them again Im biased as a benn owner.
Eberle seems to be one of those guys who is an awesome hockey player, so his fantasy value gets propped up a little more than it should. Pts only, i see him at 70 or so, and benn at 75. Didnt eberle have something like a 19% Shooting last year? Can see that dropping to the 12-13 range

[27Blue]

for fantasy purposes, and more so for points only, this is a coin flip...
if you look at real hockey value, it is nowhere near as close, as benn is clearly a far more valuable asset.

[blayze]

If it's points only I've gotta go with Eberle here...

Benn is extremely impressive, but his value is higher in multi-cat leagues.

Eberle's just surrounded by so much talent... that combined with his unreal hockey sense and the fact that he's the only right-handed shot on that team means he will continue to enjoy tremendous offensive opportunities to just rack up points for the foreseeable future.

[Hullofafan]

Points only I go with Eberle.

Multi-cat. with Benn.

[hockeymanG23]

Same story here, I'll take Eberle in a points only pool

[Rocky71]

Both are great young players. I like Benn, but Eberle is going to be a major cog on the Oil's high octane offence. Eberle will be getting top line minutes, and 1st wave PP time. Eberle for me.