Which side?

[Clutch]

Standard cats, 16 team league.



Side A: Prince, Sandoval, Bourn

for

Side B: Teixeria, Zimmerman, BJ Upton


I'd be trading side B for side A. Is it a good deal?

[bkradz]

I like side A better

[hockeyrobot]

I like side A better as well but totally depends on the cats.

[Clutch]

I like side A better as well but totally depends on the cats.

Thanks guy the cats are -

Batting Average (AVG) Home Runs (HR)
Runs (R) Runs Batted In (RBI)
Stolen Bases (SB) On Base plus Slugging Pct (OPS)

Earned Run Average (ERA)* Strikeouts (K)
Walks plus Hits Per Innings Pitched (WHIP)* Wins (W)
Saves (SV) Holds (HD)


and that's Ryan Zimmerman.

[ruckus1717]

I would definetly take side A on this.

[dmvincent]

Side A for me as well.

[Clutch]

So it's side A for everyone, I thought it would be a little closer actually. The way I saw it was:

Prince > Teixeira
Sandoval < Zimmerman
Bourn < Upton

With side B getting the slight nod. Thanks for all the replies gents.

[fastdogs]

its more like Prince >>> Teix
3rd base pretty darn close
BJ is 1 of the least popular players that has decent HR & SB #'s every year. I could see Bourn being drafted very close 2 him in most leagues this year. I've seen 2 posts of early rankings and the last 2 sets of players are nearly side by side. Teix dropping off and Prince settling in as a fantasy stud in the AL really tips this trade to 1 side

[One87]

Standard cats, 16 team league.



Side A: Prince, Sandoval, Bourn

for

Side B: Teixeria, Zimmerman, BJ Upton


I'd be trading side B for side A. Is it a good deal?

Side A by a nice margin..

[Clutch]

He also has Pedro Alvarez, would you swap out Panda for Alvarez?

[fastdogs]

Alvarez hit a ton of HR, but he's not someone I'd fully trust yet and certainly wouldn't make that swap

[Clutch]

Alvarez hit a ton of HR, but he's not someone I'd fully trust yet and certainly wouldn't make that swap

Thanks, I know Prince >>>>> Tex but how close do you see Zimm and Panda over the next couple of years?

[ruckus1717]

Take side A. Panda won't hit the hr or possibly get as many RBI as zimm but zimm is injury prone and with that lineup in SF panda will produce just fine.

[gfhyde]

Take side A. Panda won't hit the hr or possibly get as many RBI as zimm but zimm is injury prone and with that lineup in SF panda will produce just fine.

Well easy meow....Panda has played only 70% of the last 2 seasons combined (approx.). Zimmerman? 75%.

But I'd still take A I have no faith in Teix.