Downie/Shatty vs Callahan/Kronwall

[Teh Doktor]

I'm in some need of assists, and +/-. While I have apparent PIM's to spare, I'm only in the middle of the pack in the PIM's dept.

11 team roto-keeper-auction-league.
13 F, 6 D, 2 G.
$55 cap applicable only on draft day.
G, A, PIM, +/-, SGoals (1PP+2SH), Goalie pts (2W+1OTL/SOL+2shutout)


Giving:
K Shattenkirk, StL $0.75
S Downie, TB - can not keep (cost doesn't matter)

Getting:
N Kronwall, Det $0.25
R Callahan, NYR $ 1.50


I'm in it to try to win it this year.

Any help appreciated, and rep given.

[theslymonkey]

I like picking up Callahan with his current slow start, and Shatty isn't getting relied upon like he was in Colorado. So I would do the deal, but I'm not doing back flips over the move.

[bondon]

If you need assists/ +/- / PIM then to me Shattenkirk/Downie is the side I'd take. Downie will help you destroy one of your five skater categories alone and Shattenkirk IMO is a great option if you're looking for assists and +/-. I'm fairly confident that Shattenkirk will be a + player by the end of the year.

My two cents.