Mika Zibanejad, Stefan Noesen, Griffin Reinhart, 1st 2015, Ben Bishop
Max Pacioretty, Hyka, Slater Koekkoek,Olivier Roy, 2nd 2013,and 2nd 2015
Thta woulld leave me wih only Kari Lehtonen, Jaroslov Halak, Mathieu Garon, Danny Taylor.
start 2 goalies.
Im getting the pacioretty side.
I think you should stick with what you have. I don't know most of the guys listed, but with the main guys, I like Zibs better than MaxPac.
I own patches. And I wouldn't look twice at that deal. I'll take Pacioretty's side.
A lot of young guys going out for Patches and some young guys coming in.
Originally Posted by hockeynerd
Hyka and Noesen cancel each other out. Tough to say if either see the NHL. I like Reinhart more then Koekoek and think he has a better chance of making a serious impact, but both are years away from making an any impact.
Max Pac is obviously a better choice then Zibanejad today but I dont think Zibanejad is that far away from being a solid fantasy producer. You are giving up a 1st rnd pick in 2015 (thats a long way away) and Bishop. Bishop obviously trumps Olivier Roy. Tough to say what will happen with Roy. Maybe its just me but I like Bunz more going forward for the Oilers goaltending situation so I am not sure how much value he really holds in this deal.
Heres what I know. There is a lot of unknowns in this deal except for Max Pac and Zibanejad. I like Max Pac more then Zibby right now so I would probably do this deal on that basis alone and hope the rest of the unknowns fall into place as the years go by. I know that the 2013 draft should be a good one (from what I am reading) so I also like the fact you are getting another good young prospect in the summer.
I'd do it.