B. Smith vs J. Brodin
 

Points-only keeper pool with salary cap (dynasty, keep all)

Who would you rather have on defense? I'm not in a win now mode and Brodin has 2 more entry-level contract years than Smith.

Which one is in the best position to produce good offensive numbers?

Thanks in advance!

Brodin has looked fantastic by all accounts, but so has Smith, slowly working his way up to 20 mins a night. I prefer Smith here, if even to simply be able to move him in some sort of trade and pick up Brodin to replace. I would rather be a Smith owner than Brodin owner if it came down to the one option.